© 2014 COPYRIGHT PHYSICIANS POSTGRADUATE PRESS, INC. NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION, DISPLAY, OR COMMERCIAL PURPOSES.
e1 J Clin Psychiatry
Original Research
Gender Differences, Clinical Correlates, and Longitudinal
Outcome of Bipolar Disorder With Comorbid Migraine
Erika F. H. Saunders, MD; Racha Nazir, MD; Masoud Kamali, MD; Kelly A. Ryan, PhD;
Simon Evans, PhD; Scott Langenecker, PhD; Alan J. Gelenberg, MD; and Melvin G. McInnis, MD
ABSTRACT
Objective: Migraine is a common comorbidity of bipolar
disorder and is more prevalent in women than men. We
hypothesized comorbid migraine would be associated
with features of illness and psychosocial risk factors that
would differ by gender and impact outcome.
Method: A retrospective analysis was conducted to
assess association between self-reported, physician-
diagnosed migraine, clinical variables of interest,
and mood outcome in subjects with DSM-IV bipolar
disorder (N = 412) and healthy controls (N = 157) from
the Prechter Longitudinal Study of Bipolar Disorder,
2005–2010. Informed consent was obtained from all
participants.
Results: Migraine was more common in subjects with
bipolar disorder (31%) than in healthy controls (6%) and
had elevated risk in bipolar disorder women compared
to men (OR = 3.5; 95% CI, 2.1–5.8). In men, migraine
was associated with bipolar II disorder (OR = 9.9; 95% CI,
2.3–41.9) and mixed symptoms (OR = 3.5; 95% CI, 1.0–
11.9). In comparison to absence of migraine, presence
of migraine was associated with an earlier age at onset
of bipolar disorder by 2 years, more severe depression
(β = .13, P = .03), and more frequent depression
longitudinally (β = .13, P = .03). Migraine was correlated
with childhood emotional abuse (P = .01), sexual abuse
(P = 4 × 10
-3
), emotional neglect (P = .01), and high
neuroticism (P = 2 × 10
-3
). Protective factors included
high extraversion (P = .02) and high family adaptability at
the trend level (P = .08).
Conclusions: Migraine is a common comorbidity with
bipolar disorder and may impact long-term outcome
of bipolar disorder, particularly depression. Clinicians
should be alert for migraine comorbidity in women and
in men with bipolar II disorder. Effective treatment of
migraine may impact mood outcome in bipolar disorder
as well as headache outcome. Joint pathophysiologic
mechanisms between migraine and bipolar disorder
may be important pathways for future study of
treatments for both disorders.
J Clin Psychiatry
© Copyright 2014 Physicians Postgraduate Press, Inc.
Submitted: June 5, 2013; accepted November 7, 2013.
Online ahead of print: April 15, 2014 (doi:10.4088/JCP.13m08623).
Corresponding author: Erika F. H. Saunders, MD, Department of
Psychiatry, Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, Penn State
College of Medicine, 500 University Drive, PO Box 850, Mail Code:
HO73, Hershey, PA 17033-0850 (esaunders@hmc.psu.edu).
B
ipolar disorder is an illness that affects 2.1% of the population
1
and is one of the top 10 contributors of years of life lived with
disability for persons aged 15–44 years.
2
In addition, health care for
bipolar disorder costs more on a per capita basis than for depression,
asthma, coronary artery disease, or diabetes,
3
and comorbid medical
conditions negatively affect quality of life and contribute to the burden
of illness.
4–6
Migraine is a common comorbidity of bipolar disorder. In
population-based studies, the rate of migraine in the general population
is 9%–15%,
7–12
whereas the rate of migraine comorbidity with bipolar
disorder is 16%–54%.
9,10,13–17
Migraine is more prevalent in women (15%–20%) than in men
(6%),
7,12
and, although bipolar disorder has no gender differential,
comorbidities that affect women at a higher rate may be associated with
a different course of illness or presentation of bipolar disorder.
18
Women
with bipolar disorder are at higher risk for bipolar II disorder, comorbid
anxiety disorders, and suicide attempts.
19,20
We hypothesized that
individuals with comorbid migraine and bipolar disorder have features
of more severe illness, such as earlier age at onset; mixed symptoms;
suicidal ideation and psychosis; more frequent, severe, and variable
mood during longitudinal follow-up; and more severe psychosocial risk
factors, such as trauma and stressful life events. Neuroticism, a tendency
to experience negative affect such as depressed mood and anxiety, has
been associated with both migraine
21
and bipolar disorder,
22
and we
hypothesized that neuroticism would be elevated in those with migraine
and bipolar disorder. We hypothesized that the presentation of migraine
in bipolar disorder would differ by gender, specifically that women with
migraine would be more likely to have bipolar II disorder, rapid cycling,
anxiety disorders, and suicide attempts. By identifying risk factors and
outcomes associated with comorbid migraine, we highlight the need for
attention to the frequent comorbidity of migraine in bipolar disorder
and the possibility of treatments that target both illnesses.
METHOD
We retrospectively investigated differences in baseline characteristics
and longitudinal outcome in 412 subjects with DSM-IV bipolar I and II
disorder; schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type; and bipolar disorder not
otherwise specified (270 females; 142 males) and 157 healthy control
subjects (86 females; 71 males) with and without comorbid migraine.
Patients with bipolar disorder and healthy controls with no personal
or family history of mood or psychotic disorder were recruited to the
Prechter Longitudinal Study of Bipolar Disorder at the University of
Michigan between 2005 and 2010. This study was approved by the
University of Michigan Institutional Review Board; informed consent
was obtained from all participants. Diagnostic interviews were
completed with the Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies (DIGS),
23
and clinicians rated mood with the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale
(HDRS)
24
and the Young Mania Rating Scale.
25
Interviewers included
physicians, psychologists, and masters’-level mental health professionals,