Natural Resources, 2013, 4, 134-141
http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/nr.2013.41A017 Published Online March 2013 (http://www.scirp.org/journal/nr)
Scientific Catch-Up in Asian Economies: A Case Study for
Solar Cell
Ichiro Sakata
1,2
, Hajime Sasaki
2
1
Graduate School of Engineering, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan;
2
Policy Alternatives Research Institute, University of Tokyo,
Tokyo, Japan.
Email: isakata@ipr-ctr.t.u-tokyo.ac.jp, sasaki@pp.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Received January 14
th
, 2013; revised February 14
th
, 2013; accepted February 22
nd
, 2013
ABSTRACT
A significant structural change in the pattern of economic development in Asian economies has been observed in recent
years. We have seen many cases in which the Asian economies became the center of the world-wide production in an
extremely short period of time after a new product entered the market. Also in the science, the number of papers written
by Asian researchers has been increasing dramatically. In this situation, the existing studies cannot sufficiently explain
the driving force and the mechanism of catch-up or economic growth. Therefore, it is now required to model this new
type of economic development. In this paper we analyzed their scientific catch-up status using scientific papers on solar
cells to clarify the structural change. After mid 1990s, knowledge creation has been accelerated in the field of solar cell.
Now more than three thousand papers are published annually. We found as a result that the catch-up process in Asian
economies had progressed rapidly, that some economies had a larger share of scientific papers in the frontier field of
advanced science than in the matured fields, and that the strategy largely changed from area to area. A “parallel-run-
ning-type growth model” has thus been emerging in Asia. Responding to the significant changes in development model,
we have to re-design the framework of economic cooperation. There is a need for further horizontal collaboration
among major Asian economies and developed economies. We also showed that bibliometrics is an effective method for
presuming a detailed national strategy that is not known to the outside.
Keywords: Catch-Up; Growth Model; Bibliometrics
1. Introduction
In fields such as development economics, political sci-
ence, and innovation research, many studies have been
conducted on the process in which the developing econo-
mies catch up with the advanced economies and on the
convergence of the disparity. In particular, East Asia has
been the central target of the researches [1-9]. They can
be classified according to the analysis targets: the studies
on the production capabilities, those on the innovation
capabilities, and those on the fundamentals and policies
that affect these capabilities. Most of the studies use
models in which the developing economies catch up with
the advanced economies and gradually progress in the
same development process as did the advanced econo-
mies A typical model is the flying goose pattern of in-
dustrialization [10,11]. Also, most of the papers focusing
on the innovation capabilities are studies on the transfer
or development of the industrial technologies, conducted
on the basis of patent data. In contrast, there are few re-
searches on the catch-up processes in the science. In the
21st century, however, we have seen many cases in which
the developing economies became the center of the
world-wide production in an extremely short period of
time after a new product entered the market, such as
LCD TVs, solar cells, and cellular phones. Also in the
science, the number of papers written by Chinese or In-
dians has been increasing dramatically and the structure
of the geographical distribution of scientific knowledge
is significantly changing [12]. In this situation, the exist-
ing studies cannot sufficiently explain the driving force
and the mechanism of catch-up or economic growth.
Therefore, it is now required to model this new type of
economic development. This paper aims to focus on the
catch-up processes in the science and clarify the current
situation. We will also discuss the differences among the
economies and the causes for the differences.
We selected solar cell as a subject to analysis. Sus-
tainable and renewable energies have been widely ac-
cepted as a key concept for our common future [13]. A
solar cell or photovoltaic cell, which is a device that
converts solar energy into electricity via the photovoltaic
effect, represents a promising research front for our fu-
ture sustainable ecosystem. The solar cell systems can be
Copyright © 2013 SciRes. NR