THE PRESENCE OF BILATERAL IMBALANCE OF THE
LOWER LIMBS IN ELITE YOUTH SOCCER PLAYERS
OF DIFFERENT AGES
STEPHEN J. ATKINS,IAN BENTLEY,HOWARD T. HURST,JONATHAN K. SINCLAIR, AND
CHRISTOPHER HESKETH
Centre for Applied Sport and Exercise Sciences, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, England, United Kingdom
ABSTRACT
Atkins, S, Bentley, I, Hurst, H, Sinclair, J, and Hesketh, C. The
presence of bilateral imbalance of the lower limbs in elite youth
soccer players of different ages. J Strength Cond Res 30(4):
1007–1013, 2016—The aim of this study was to examine bilat-
eral differences in ground reaction forces (GRF), measured
during a deep squat (DS) exercise, in a population of elite youth
soccer players. Bilateral muscle balance is a key component in
promoting musculoskeletal health of performers, yet there is a lim-
ited evidence base investigating such imbalances in youth.
Seventy-four subjects were assigned to performance groups ac-
cording to chronological age (younger than 13, 14, 15, 16, 17
years). Analysis of physical maturity status revealed that very few
players were classified as “early” or “late” maturers. Players com-
pleted an overhead DS exercise, as part of preseason functional
movement screening. Peak GRF were assessed using a twin
force plate system. Significant differences (p # 0.05) were iden-
tified between right and left side peak GRF for all groups except
the youngest (U13) and oldest (U17). Nondominant “sides”
showed the highest levels of PGRF across all groups. The mag-
nitude of PGRF was not significantly different both within and
between groups, except for the left side in the U13 to U15
groups (p = 0.04). Results from this study show that performance
asymmetry is marked in adolescence. There seems a “trigger
point” during the early stage of adolescence, when bilateral im-
balances become marked. These differences do seem to reduce
during the later stages of adolescence. Correct attention to
focussed training, designed to remediate any imbalance, is war-
ranted in adolescent groups. This is important with respect of the
key associations between bilateral asymmetry and risk of injury.
KEY WORDS adolescence, ground reaction forces, squat,
bilateral balance, asymmetry
INTRODUCTION
B
ilateral movements, evidencing symmetry and
balance within the human, are the foundation
of many simple and complex human movements.
In the performance context, it is important to
maintain symmetrical balance between the right and left
sides. Fluctuating bilateral asymmetry is reportedly common
in humans (50,52). Asymmetry across the body can be linked
to increased prevalence of injury and impaired sports perfor-
mance (3,4,11,20,39,42,43,52). The unilateral demands of
sporting performance have been linked with mechanical adap-
tations (27). A bilateral imbalance in lower body strength,
whether in accordance with handedness, preferred foot, or
side dominance measured by ground reaction forces (GRF),
have been identified in adults (15,26,28,36). Such imbalances
may affect performance and also increase the incidence of
injury (2,11,12,36,43). Although the evidence supporting such
imbalances is somewhat compelling in adult populations, there
is a marked dearth of research investigating such imbalances in
youth. Additionally, the contribution of both chronological
and biological age has received limited attention in functional
performance settings, particularly when considering human
movement symmetry.
The screening of functional movement has become an
integral part of both preseason and inseason assessment. At
youth levels, such assessments are regularly undertaken to
assess both functional capabilities and the potential for muscu-
loskeletal injury. Functional movement is classified as the ability
to produce and maintain balance between mobility and stability
through the kinetic chain (32,38). Such balance should ensure
that fundamental movement patterns are performed with
utmost accuracy and efficiency (32). The assessment of func-
tional performance can provide an useful insight into the
strength, flexibility, balance, and coordination necessary for
a variety of movements (32). This may also provide a mecha-
nism to assess bilateral imbalances in the upper and lower body.
Although quantitative analysis of functional movement is
often the preserve of laboratory-based testing, advances have
been made with regard to effective field-based methods of
assessment. Recently, test batteries such as the Functional
Movement Screen (FMS) have been shown to be reliable
There are no external funding streams associated with this research.
Address correspondence to Dr. Stephen Atkins, satkins@uclan.ac.uk.
30(4)/1007–1013
Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research
Ó 2013 National Strength and Conditioning Association
VOLUME 30 | NUMBER 4 | APRIL 2016 | 1007
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.