Wear 267 (2009) 718–725
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Wear
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/wear
Influence of pH values and aging time on the tribological behaviour of posterior
restorative materials
P. Vale Antunes
a,b,∗
, A. Ramalho
a
a
CEMUC, University of Coimbra, Portugal
b
EST - Instituto Politecnico de Castelo Branco, Portugal
article info
Article history:
Received 22 September 2008
Received in revised form 19 December 2008
Accepted 19 December 2008
Keywords:
Dental composites
Wear
pH effect
abstract
Besides the complexity of the contact between teeth, the mouth is also a very specific service environment.
Dental restorative materials, and teeth, are subjected to very specific service conditions, wide-ranging
temperatures, contact loading, loading rates, sliding conditions and pH variation. Several studies have
established that an exposure of resin composites to aqueous environments lowers their mechanical prop-
erties. Due to changes in the structure of these materials, softening of the resin matrix and/or bond failure
in the outer layer of the filler and in the filler–matrix interface region reduce the mechanical and tribo-
logical performance. During the day, the mouth presents different values of pH, and thus it is important
to determine the effect of pH on the composites’ tribological behaviour. The main objective of this study
is the determination of the nature of the dependency between the tribological behaviour of commercial
composites and the influence of values of pH and aging time. Seven commercial resin composites, con-
densable and suitable for posterior restoration, have been characterized. Each material composite was
aged during a period of 3, 6 and 22 months at a temperature of 37
◦
C, and considering three values of pH:
3, 7 and 9. The tribological behaviour was evaluated in a reciprocating contact against glass spheres. At the
end of the tests, the wear was assessed on the composite and also on the counterface. The removal mech-
anisms enclosed in the wear process are discussed, taking into account the systematic SEM observations
to evaluate the failure modes.
© 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The warm, wet nature of the mouth is a very specific environ-
ment that demands a great deal from resin restorative materials,
especially in order for these materials to maintain reasonable sta-
bility in terms of mechanical and tribological behaviours. Bathed in
saliva with an average pH near 7, humidity of 100% and constantly
altered environmental conditions, namely temperature and pH, due
to the introduction of food and even due to dental treatments, these
resin restorative materials have to show their operating capabilities
in such an environment.
Within the last few years, several new types of resin composites
have been introduced to the market. The new classes are packable
(condensable) composites, universal composites, reinforced micro-
fills and nano-filled composites.
The restorative materials and teeth are subjected to a high range
of physical and chemical conditions. Some of these variables were
already objects of study but their influence on the mechanical
∗
Corresponding author at: EST - Instituto Politecnico de Castelo Branco, Portugal.
Tel.: +351 272339300; fax: +351 272339399.
E-mail address: pedrov@est.ipcb.pt (P.V. Antunes).
and tribological behaviour is not well known. The warm, aqueous,
chemical environment is one aspect of the oral environment that
has an appreciable influence on the in vivo degradation of resin
composites. The in vivo evaluation of restorative materials is gen-
erally, besides ethical reasons, very complicated, time-consuming
and expensive. Thus, in vitro aging studies are more often used
and performed in various aging media. Among these, the most
frequently used are water and ethanol/water solutions [1,2]. It is
well established that the exposure of resin composites to an aque-
ous environment lowers their mechanical properties [3,4]. When
stresses are applied to composites, these are absorbed by the resin
matrix and transferred through the coupling agent to the stiffer,
inorganic filler particles. Several mechanisms have been suggested
to explain the decrease of mechanical properties after aging in
various liquids, mostly softening of the resin matrix and/or bond
failures occurring in the outer layer of the filler, in the silane coat-
ing, at the silane–matrix interfacial region or within the matrix. It is
not known where such “interphase” failures are induced, and which
of the above regions can be regarded as the weakest links of a dental
composite [5].
Nowadays, composite materials show a good clinical longevity
[6], although problems due to fractures, increased surface rough-
ness and microleakage have been reported. Failures due to
0043-1648/$ – see front matter © 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wear.2008.12.054