Open Forum
International Journal of Iberian Studies Volume 21 Number 1 © 2008 Intellect Ltd
Open Forum. English language. doi: 10.1386/ijis.21.1.41/3
Outstanding challenges in a
post-equality era: The same-sex marriage
and gender identity laws in Spain
Raquel Platero Complutense University of Madrid
Abstract
Spain has captured international attention with regards to equality for sexual
minorities, recently approving laws that allow same-sex couples to marry under
the same conditions as different-sex couples (Law 13/2005) and that allow
transgender people to change their name in the register without having to go
through compulsory surgery (Law 3/2007). Using intersectionality as a frame-
work for my analysis, I explore the limitations of the notion of equality in both
legal texts by adding an analysis that includes not only sexuality, but also gender,
ethnicity, age, and class. Both laws aimed at satisfying the demands of social
movements and were designed to overcome inequality and have a relevant sym-
bolic impact. Despite this, it is argued, they were not framed to transform society
in depth. Both laws are contributing to reproduce inequality by not taking into
account multiple discriminations.
The regulation of sexuality has evolved rapidly in recent years, with the cre-
ation of not only new sexual identities and social movements around sexual
practices, but also new civil rights. According to Laraña and Gusfield (1994),
we have been witnessing the way that complex social networks have arisen
in developed capitalist societies, and seen how groups were organised around
sexuality along with the incipient women’s movements, and then went on to
claim a collective identity of their own and also took to the streets.
Lately, sexual minorities have been normalised through several public
policies in Spain: from the decriminalisation of homosexuality with the new
Civil Code (1995) to the consecutive adoption of civil partnership laws in
twelve autonomous communities,
1
and the changes in the Civil Code which
allow marriage between same-sex couples (Law 13/2005) and the Law of
Registration of Rectification of Sex – the latter unfortunately known as the
Gender Identity Law (3/2007) (see Platero 2007a). These changes have
taken place at the same time as public services for gays and transgenders
1 In chronological
order: Catalonia (Law
10/1998 reformed by
Law 3/2005), Aragon
(Law 6/1999),
Navarra (Law
6/2000), Valencia
(Law 1/2001),
Madrid (Law
11/2001), Balear
Islands (Law
18/2001), Asturias
(Law 4/2002),
Andalusia (Law
5/2002), Canary
Islands (Law 5/2003),
Extremadura (Law
5/2003), Basque
Country (Law
2/2003), and
41 IJIS 21 (1) 41–49 © Intellect Ltd 2008
Keywords
Gay, lesbian and
transgender rights
same-sex marriage
intersectionality