Characterization of Hysteresis of Surface Energy in
Room-Temperature Direct Bonding Processes
David S. Grierson and Kevin T. Turner
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Wisconsin
Madison, WI 53706 USA
Room temperature direct wafer bonding is driven by surface forces
and the formation of hydrogen bonds that pull the wafers being
bonded into intimate contact. The magnitude of these forces is
often represented as a work of adhesion, and is critical as it
determines the level of non-flatness and patterning that may be
tolerated in bonding. Traditionally, it has been assumed that the
work of adhesion that drives the formation of the bond is equal to
the work of separation that is measured through fracture tests, such
as the familiar razor-blade test. In the present work, we use a
novel test structure to measure both the work of separation and the
work of adhesion of room temperature hydrophilic Si-Si bonds as a
function of relative humidity (~15 – 50% RH). The results show
that across a range of values of RH, the work of adhesion is
significantly lower than the work of separation.
Introduction
Direct wafer bonding is an important process that enables the fabrication of a wide range
of micro- and nanosystems (1). This process is commonly used in the fabrication of SOI
substrates (2) and complex multi-wafer MEMS devices (3). In direct bonding, initial
adhesion between the wafers is typically achieved at room temperature via van der Waals
forces and hydrogen bonding. The strength of the adhesion is commonly described in
terms of a single parameter, the work of adhesion (W
adh
). The work of adhesion of
bonded wafer pairs is most commonly measured with the razor-blade test (4), which is
essentially a fracture test. The value of work of adhesion measured in the test is truly a
work of separation value, rather than a work of adhesion value. Here, we measure both
the work of adhesion and work of separation to establish if they are equal to one another
in room temperature silicon direct bonding.
Previous researchers have used microfabrication techniques to develop
measurement schemes for studying stiction between polycrystalline silicon beams and
silicon substrates with various surface coatings as a function of humidity [(5, 6), for
example]. These techniques have proven to be beneficial in understanding adhesion
between micromachined surfaces, but are limited in their ability to fully characterize the
adhesion and separation behavior bonded interfaces directly, and the range of material
pairs is also limited.
The novel measurement approach detailed here is similar to the previous
micromachined beam studies reported previously, but is distinct in that the beams are not
ECS Transactions, 33 (4) 573-580 (2010)
10.1149/1.3483549 ©The Electrochemical Society
573
Downloaded 29 Nov 2010 to 146.151.127.221. Redistribution subject to ECS license or copyright; see http://www.ecsdl.org/terms_use.jsp