Anaerobic Co‐digestion of Dairy Cattle Slurry and Agro‐industrial
Fats: Effect of Fat Ratio on the Digester Efficiency
Sébastien Guillaume
1,2
and Thomas Lendormi
2
1. Forafrance, Rue de l'aiguillage ZA de beauséjour 35520 LA MEZIERE, France
2. Univ. Bretagne‐Sud, EA 4250 LIMATB, F‐56300, Pontivy, France
The objective of the study was to optimize the co‐digestion of cattle slurry in the presence of fats from the food industry. A laboratory pilot plant
operating continuously was used for the experimental study. Tests were carried out with only cattle slurry and with different fat ratio (0, 10, 25, 45 and
60 %
w/w
of the feed COD as fats). In the case of using cattle slurry feed and OLR from 0.4 and 3.0 kg VS Á m
À3
Á day
À1
(HRT between 125 days and 19
days), methane productivity versus OLR exhibit a linear relation reflecting optimum biodegradability of the organic matter. For OLR above 3 kg
VS Á m
À3
Á day
À1
(HRT less than 19 days), a break in the slope is observed expressing a decrease of the organic matter degradation rate. For HRT equal
to 30 days, the results show that fat incorporation ratio lower than 25 %
w/w
does not affect the digester operation while maintaining acceptable
biodegradability of the fat. In contrast, with a fat ratio of 60 %
w/w
, the system became unstable and a significant decrease in the methane productivity
was observed, due to an accumulation of undegraded Long Chain Fatty Acids (LCFA). The conclusion is that the fat ratio must be controlled to avoid
the destabilization of digestion, and finally operational conditions are proposed for co‐digestion.
Keywords: anaerobic digestion, dairy cattle slurry, agro‐industrial greases, LCFAs
INTRODUCTION
F
or many years, the production of organic waste has increased
due to more intensive farming practices, industrialization,
treatment processes and waste collection. This waste
management (livestock manure, food industry waste, etc.) has
become a major environmental issue and is increasingly oriented
towards valorization and recycling. In order to address these
environmental issues, biological treatment and biomass valoriza-
tion processes are implemented, including anaerobic digestion.
Anaerobic digestion is a biological process which converts the
organic matter into carbon dioxide and usable methane, a fossil
fuel substitute. In this context, anaerobic digestion of organic waste
has been widely developed in Europe in recent years with the
objective to establish public policies to reduce energy dependency
and Green House Gases (GHG) emissions, by reducing direct
emissions released from waste management. Anaerobic digestion
of manure is particularly interesting in relation to this objective to
reduce GHG emissions in manure management.
[1]
In addition,
manures, especially slurry, are interesting substrates due to their
nutrient intake for the development of micro‐organisms responsi-
ble for anaerobic digestion and their high buffering capacity to
stabilize the process. However, their high dilution rate, <10 %
w/w
Dry Matter (DM), and limited biodegradability of organic matter
(10–60 %
w/w
), generate a relatively low Biochemical Methane
Potential (BMP) relative to their volume (for example, 4–20 Nm
3
CH
4
Á m
À3
for pig and cattle slurry). This low BMP leads to high
costs for developing plants in relation to the low associated energy
production. Thus, the economic viability of biogas plants requires
additional substrates with higher methane potential or through co‐
digestion with one or more substrates containing a higher methane
potential.
[2–4]
Many operators are looking for co‐substrates with
high methanogen potential to increase their methane production in
the digester. Industrial co‐substrates usually sought after are
flotation fats from Waste Water Treatment Plant (WWTP). These
lipid‐rich products are known to combine both a high methanogen
potential and good organic matter biodegradability. However,
adding fatty co‐substrates may have a detrimental effect on bacteria
when introduced at high concentration or loading rates.
[5–7]
Fatty
co‐substrates may induce micro‐organisms flotation phenomena
and aggregate them in a hydrophobic capsule which can reduce the
performance of the digester. Pereira et al.
[8]
have shown that the
degradation of such substrate could lead to the production of Long
Chain Fatty Acids (LCFA) in the digester which can disturb the
anaerobic digestion process in different ways: (1) Mass transfer
limitation phenomena resulting from LCFAs adsorption on micro‐
organisms can lead to a hydrophobic layer around this biomass. (2)
LCFA trapping in the biomass aggregates may result in the flotation
of the biomass in the reactor and washout. (3) LCFA can extract in
organic droplets Volatile Fatty Acids (VFA) that are essential
reaction intermediates for the production of methane. (4) LCFA
precipitation with divalent ions such as Ca
2þ
or Mg
2þ
makes them
inaccessible to the anaerobic biomass and thus reduces their
biodegradability. In addition, the Carbon/Nitrogen (C/N) ratio of
lipid‐rich substrates is often above the optimum values 20–30
defined by Parkin and Owen
[9]
which may lead to a lack of
nutrients when an excess of that substrate is used.
The anaerobic digestion inhibition of rich lipid substrates caused
by these phenomena has been reported in the literature. Many
authors have mentioned the reversible inhibition of methano-
genesis and other anaerobic digestion stages by LCFA.
[10–15]
Accordingly, most of these studies were performed in batch and
latency phenomena show different phases of the methane and
*Author to whom correspondence may be addressed.
E‐mail address: thomas.lendormi@univ-ubs.fr
Can. J. Chem. Eng. 93:304–308, 2015
©
2014 Canadian Society for Chemical Engineering
DOI 10.1002/cjce.22118
Published online 18 December 2014 in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com).
304 THE CANADIAN JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING VOLUME 93, FEBRUARY 2015