International Journal of Innovation and Scientific Research
ISSN 2351-8014 Vol. 54 No. 2 May. 2021, pp. 56-63
© 2021 Innovative Space of Scientific Research Journals
http://www.ijisr.issr-journals.org/
Corresponding Author: Emmalia Adriantantri 56
The reduction of bullwhip effect by Integrating Information Sharing,
Forecasting, Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) - Vendor Management
Inventory (VMI) - and Consignment (Cs) Approach
Emmalia Adriantantri and Sri Indriani
Industrial Engineering, National Institute of Technology, Malang, East Java, Indonesia
Copyright © 2021 ISSR Journals. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT: This research aims to create a conceptual method, in order to reduce the effect of bullwhip by integrating
information sharing, Forecasting, Economic Order Quantity (EOQ), Vendor Management Inventory (VMI), and Consignment
(Cs) methods. The results are used to build an application that can be used for information sharing, simulation using forecasting,
and Economic Order Quantity-Vendor Management Inventory-Consignment methods, which can reduce the effect of bullwhip.
It can be concluded that through information sharing, the results obtained in the forecasting method is more accurate, because
customer requests can be identified by suppliers and retailers. Also, the optimal product lot size and total cost was obtained
by using the Economic Order Quantity-Vendor Management Inventory-Consignment model. These aforementioned integration
steps were taken as an effort to reduce the effect of bullwhip.
KEYWORDS: Bullwhip Effect, Information Sharing, EOQ, VMI-Consignment, Inventory.
1 INTRODUCTION
In today's industrial world, the level of competition is getting higher, hence, companies should be able to compete in order
to survive. This is because, the higher the level of competition, the more the consumers are able to benefit from the large
selection of products or services available, such that they are increasingly critical about the quality of the products and services
offered. Therefore, the company must be able to take strategic steps in order to compete in winning the market and achieve
maximum production results to meet market demand. A strategic step that companies can take is to maintain good
coordination between retailers, suppliers, and factories that form a chain called the supply chain. What often happens in the
supply chain is information distortion, resulting in variations in demand, this event is called the bullwhip effect [1]
According to Jiang, Q. and Ke, G. (2019), the Bullwhip effect is a situation that occurs in the supply chain where demand
from customers changes. These changes can cause various impacts, thereby resulting in the disruption of the supply chain. For
instance, the amount of product demand that is always changing with fixed ordering times and the lack of accurate
communication will cause various kinds of disruptions to the supply chain, such as an increase and varied demand from
upstream to downstream [2]. Hence, adequate research is needed to be carried out in order to solve this problem.
The causes of the bullwhip effect include, the accumulation of orders, processing customer requests, waiting time for
product orders to arrive, price changes, distrust from other parties, and the company's product inventory policy [4]. On the
other hand, the ways to reduce this effect are, sharing information, reducing lead time, changing supply chain structures,
creating price stability, and reducing costs [5].
Based on this description, it is necessary to integrate several methods that can be used to overcome the causes of this
bullwhip effect. This will make products to be available in a timely manner and in quantity to meet customer demands.