Difference in petrophysical properties between foliated and
dilatant fault rocks in deeply buried clastics: The case of the
Gr
es d’Annot Formation, SW French Alps
Thibault Cavailhes,
1
Pierre Labaume,
1
Jean-Pierre Sizun,
2
Roger Soliva,
1
Claude Gout,
3
Jean-Luc
Potdevin,
4
Martine Buatier,
2
Aur elien Gay,
1
Alain Chauvet,
1
Delphine Charpentier
2
and Anna Trav e
5
1
G eosciences Montpellier (UMR 5243), Universit e Montpellier 2 – CNRS, Montpellier, France;
2
Chrono-Environnement (UMR6249),
Universit e de Franche-Comt e – CNRS, Besanc ßon France;
3
Total Exploration et Production, Pau, France;
4
G eosyst emes (UMR 8217),
Universit e Lille 1 – CNRS, Villeneuve d’Ascq, France;
5
Facultat de Geologia, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
ABSTRACT
This study describes normal fault zones formed in foreland
arkosic turbidites (the Gr es d’Annot Formation, SW French
Alps) under deep diagenesis conditions (~200 °C) and high-
lights the occurrence of two markedly different fault-rock
types: (1) the foliated fault rocks of the Mouti ere-Restefond
area; and (2) the dilatant fault rocks of the Estrop area. The
deformation of (1) is dominated by intra- and transgranular
fracturing, pressure solution of quartz and feldspar grains
and syn-kinematic phyllosilicate precipitation resulting from
feldspar alteration. The combination of these mechanisms
results in a strongly anisotropic strain with intense shortening
normal to the foliation (pressure solution) and extension par-
allel to the foliation (quartz- and calcite-sealed extension
veins). This deformation implies local mass transfer that may
be achieved without (or with limited) volume change. The
deformation of (2) is expressed as dilatant quartz-sealed veins
and breccia textures in which the main mechanisms are trans-
granular fracturing and quartz precipitation. Type (2) implies
fault volume increase, isotropy of deformation and mass
transfer at distances larger than in type (1). This study dis-
cusses the origins of (1) and (2) and shows that the perme-
ability of (1) is anisotropic, with higher values than the host
rocks parallel to the Y main deformation axis (i.e. perpendicu-
lar to the slip vector), whereas the permeability of (2) is
isotropic and equivalent to that of the host rocks.
Terra Nova, 26, 298–306, 2014
Introduction
Predicting the hydraulic behaviour of
faults is one of the most uncertain
processes in the understanding of
upper-crust fluid flow (Corrigan,
1993; Fisher and Knipe, 2001). Fault-
related fluid redistribution is signifi-
cantly influenced by hydraulic
gradient, in-situ stress conditions,
fluid characteristics and fault-rock
properties (e.g. Faulkner and Rutter,
1998; Manzocchi et al., 1999; Sibson,
2000; Yielding, 2002; Eichhubl et al.,
2009; Faulkner et al., 2010; Gud-
mundsson et al., 2010). The latter are
a key parameter that is mainly related
to the nature and mechanical proper-
ties of the protolith, the fault offset,
the rock and fluid pressures and tem-
peratures at the time of faulting and
how the resulting fluid–rock inter-
actions enhanced mineral dissolution
or/and precipitation (e.g. Solum
et al., 2005, 2010; Ajdukiewicz and
Lander, 2010; Onasch et al., 2010;
Pollington et al., 2011). Understand-
ing the relationships between the
different kinds of fault rocks and
their petrophysical properties is par-
ticularly important for the 5- to 8-km
burial interval, which corresponds
both to part of the seismogenic zone
(Maggi et al., 2000) and to deeply
buried reservoirs, an increasingly
important target for hydrocarbon
and mining exploration (Fisher et al.,
2003; Laubach and Ward, 2006).
Here, we study two types of fault
rocks related to normal fault zones
formed in the Gr es d’Annot Forma-
tion, an arkosic turbidite succession
of the SW-Alpine foreland basin,
under deep diagenesis conditions
(around 200°C) (Cavailhes, 2012;
Lecl ere et al., 2012; Cavailhes et al.,
2013a,b). Two study areas were
selected, such that the following
parameters were similar at the time
of faulting: the protolith lithology,
the fault offset, the mechanical prop-
erties linked with burial diagenesis
and the P–T conditions. This similar-
ity in properties and conditions
allows us to discuss the role of fluids
in the development of two different
types of fault-zone structures where
mechanical and chemical processes
that control the deformation mecha-
nisms are intimately linked. We also
assess the anisotropy in permeability
of the fault rock in accordance with
the structural deformation orienta-
tion and compare it with the host-
rock values. This study highlights the
relationship between the strain ellip-
soid and the permeability ellipsoid in
a fault zone.
Geological setting
The Gr es d’Annot Fm. was depos-
ited during the Priabonian-Rupelian
in the SW-Alpine foreland basin and
buried under the Embrunais-Ubaye
nappes soon after deposition (Ker-
ckhove, 1969; Joseph and Lomas,
2004) (Fig. 1A). The Miocene uplift
associated with basement thrusting
resulted in the exhumation of the
Gr es d’Annot (Labaume et al., 2008)
and the formation of several genera-
tions of normal faults (Labaume
et al., 1989). The studied normal
faults are located in two distinct
Correspondence: Thibault Cavailhes,
DNO International ASA, Bryggegata 9,
Aker Brygge, 0250 Oslo, Norway. E-mail:
thibault.cavailhes@dno.no
298 © 2014 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
doi: 10.1111/ter.12100