Algebra Universalis
Duality in non-abelian algebra III. Normal categories
and 0-regular varieties
Zurab Janelidze and Thomas Weighill
Abstract. Normal categories are pointed categorical counterparts of 0-regular vari-
eties, i.e., varieties where each congruence is uniquely determined by the equivalence
class of a fixed constant 0. In this paper, we give a new axiomatic approach to nor-
mal categories, which uses self-dual axioms on a functor defined using subobjects of
objects in the category. We also show that a similar approach can be developed for
0-regular varieties, if we replace subobjects with subsets of algebras containing 0.
1. Introduction
Axiomatic duality in categories goes back to [35]. In that paper Mac Lane
proposes to use dual axioms on a category (equipped perhaps with an ad-
ditional structure) for generalizing and organizing results, such as the iso-
morphism theorems, from the concrete context of groups. He then lists such
axioms suitable for the context of abelian groups, and arrives at the notion
of an abelian bicategory, which is a predecessor of the present-day notion of
an abelian category [10, 20, 36]. Although there were attempts to look at
the case of non-abelian groups, and in particular by Wyler [46] (see also the
work of Terlikowska-Os lowska [40]), this direction of research did not per-
sist (instead, it inspired a non-dual axiomatic development—see [25] and the
references there), while Wyler himself shifted his interest to categorical topol-
ogy, where he introduced topological theories [47], which up to the so-called
Grothendieck construction are the same as what today are known as topo-
logical functors (see [9] and references there)—faithful Grothendieck bifibra-
tions whose fibres are complete lattices. The thesis of this series of papers
is that the structure of a topological theory, and its natural variations, pro-
vide a convenient language for work on the “duality for groups hypothesis”:
homomorphism theorems for groups can be established in a category-theoretic
Presented by J. Adamek.
Received May 19, 2014; accepted in final form June 12, 2015.
2010 Mathematics Subject Classification : Primary: 18C99; Secondary: 08A30, 08B05,
08C05, 18A20, 18A32, 18D30, 18G50.
Key words and phrases : abelian category, axiomatic duality, exact form, Grothendieck fi-
bration, homological category, form of subobjects, ideal-determined variety, normal category,
0-permutable variety, protomodular category, 0-regular variety, semi-abelian category, sub-
object fibration, subtractive category, subtractive variety, universalizer, variety with ideals.
Supported by the South African National Research Foundation (both authors) and the
MIH Media Lab at Stellenbosch University (second author).
Algebra Univers. 77 (2017) 1–28
DOI 10.1007/s00012-017-0422-7
Published online January 17, 2017
© Springer International Publishing 2017