Observatorio (OBS* ) Journal, 5 (2008), 079-097 1646-5954/ERC123483/2008 079
‘Thick’ personas – Using ethnographic Methods for Persona Development
as a Tool for Conveying the Social Science View in Technological Design
An Jacobs, Katrien Dreessen, Jo Pierson, IBBT Research Group SMIT - Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB), Belgium
Abstract
Designing and developing successful technological innovations requires interdisciplinary research
teams, where engineers and social scientists profoundly interact with each other. In this kind of co-
operation it is often the challenge for the latter to present the social science findings in such a way
that they are understandable and actionable for engineering. One of the tools to bridge both worlds
is the use of ‘personas’. In this paper we want to explain our experience with the development of
well functioning personas. We believe that an optimal approach is multi-methodological. Based on
the scope of two research projects this paper will first elaborate on the advantages and limitations of
using personas in an interdisciplinary environment. Second it will also discuss the ways in which a
combination of different (quantitative and qualitative ethnographic) methods of data collection
served as input for the construction of efficient personas and the added value of this approach. The
different methods make it possible to obtain ‘thick descriptions’ (Geertz, 1973) about the different
user practices. To communicate these results without losing the advantages of ‘thick descriptions’,
‘thick’ personas are necessary.
1. I ntroduction
Together with other applied social scientists (e.g. Hughes et al. 2000), we experienced the problem to
embed our user insights early in the development process. Communication is the main obstacle: the
different partners often do not or cannot read the classical, extensive reports with the output. A possible
solution is making use of personas, as introduced by Cooper (2004). However there is still too little
information available concerning the practical implementation of this approach for sharing key research
findings in an interdisciplinary way.
The paper takes a closer look at the creation process of personas, based on two different projects within
the IBBT (Interdisciplinary Institute for Broadband Technology) framework. The key question is whether
this creation process is easily transposable to different research projects in different phases of the product
development process. In other words, has the phase in the development process wherein the research
project is situated an impact on the actual creation process of personas? How does creating personas
coincide with the research and the scenario development?
Before discussing these projects and the different approaches in creating personas, we introduce some
theoretical aspects of personas and how they are created.
Copyright © 2008 (An Jacobs et al.). Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial No Derivatives
(by-nc-nd). Available at http://obs.obercom.pt.