Eur. Phys. J. C (2021) 81:931
https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-021-09742-0
Regular Article - Theoretical Physics
From quantum field theory to quantum mechanics
Nuno Barros e Sá
1,2,a
, Cláudio Gomes
1,3
1
DCFQE, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia da Universidade dos Açores, 9500-801 Ponta Delgada, Portugal
2
OKEANOS, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia da Universidade dos Açores, 9901-862 Horta, Portugal
3
Centro de Física das Universidades do Minho e do Porto, Rua do Campo Alegre, 4169-007 Porto, Portugal
Received: 30 July 2021 / Accepted: 10 October 2021
© The Author(s) 2021
Abstract The purpose of this article is to construct an
explicit relation between the field operators in Quantum Field
Theory and the relevant operators in Quantum Mechanics for
a system of N identical particles, which are the symmetrised
functions of the canonical operators of position and momen-
tum, thus providing a clear relation between Quantum Field
Theory and Quantum Mechanics. This is achieved in the con-
text of the non-interacting Klein–Gordon field. Though this
procedure may not be extendible to interacting field theo-
ries, since it relies crucially on particle number conserva-
tion, we find it nevertheless important that such an explicit
relation can be found at least for free fields. It also comes
out that whatever statistics the field operators obey (either
commuting or anticommuting), the position and momentum
operators obey commutation relations. The construction of
position operators raises the issue of localizability of particles
in Relativistic Quantum Mechanics, as the position operator
for a single particle turns out to be the Newton–Wigner posi-
tion operator. We make some clarifications on the interpreta-
tion of Newton–Wigner localized states and we consider the
transformation properties of position operators under Lorentz
transformations, showing that they do not transform as ten-
sors, rather in a manner that preserves the canonical commu-
tation relations. From a complex Klein–Gordon field, posi-
tion and momentum operators can be constructed for both
particles and antiparticles.
Introduction
Since its inception, Quantum Field Theory suffered from a
number of problems, perhaps most notably: it inherited the
conceptual problems already present in the interpretation of
Quantum Mechanics; the theory is plagued with infinities
– despite the successes of renormalization, the situation is
uncomfortable – ; and the theory is not “dynamical”, i.e., it
a
e-mail: nuno.bf.sa@uac.pt (corresponding author)
does not provide for a picture of the spacial and temporal
evolution of a system.
None of these problems have had up to now a satisfactory
resolution. Nevertheless, no one questions the validity of both
theories, Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Field Theory,
as their successes have been so overwhelming, and many
people believe that the resolution of these problems shall
come someday. Even if these theories are not “correct”, it is
legitimate to believe that they must be correct in “some limit”,
as their validity has been solidly proven experimentally in
many domains.
Given the proximity between Quantum Mechanics in first
and second quantisation, it would be sensible too to find the
“limit” when Quantum Field Theory can be approximated by
Quantum Mechanics, that is, Quantum Mechanics should be
contained in Quantum Field Theory, because the former deals
with quantum systems with fixed number of particles while
the latter deals with arbitrary numbers of particles. While
there are some methods that allow one to recover single parti-
cle Quantum Mechanics from Quantum Field theory (see [1]
for an extensive review on propagator methods and [2, Chap.
33], for approximative methods in the context of effective
field theories), it would be interesting to construct an explicit
relation between the two. Such a task seems formidable for
interacting field theories.
Here we propose a method by which from a theory for a
free quantum field (the Klein–Gordon field, for simplicity)
one can construct all the quantum mechanical systems with
fixed numbers of particles in first quantization. In particu-
lar, we construct the algebra of operators in first quantisation
(that is, the x ’s and p’s, or rather their symmetrized combi-
nations, for systems with more than one particle) from the
field operators in second quantisation. We find it rewarding
that, at least for free theories, the reduction of Quantum Field
Theory to Quantum Mechanics can be done - and can be done
for any number of particles.
0123456789().: V,-vol
123