SOUTH ASIA
RESEARCH
www.sagepublications.com
DOI: 10.1177/0262728017725624
Vol. 37(3): 1–19
Copyright © 2017
SAGE Publications
Los Angeles,
London,
New Delhi,
Singapore,
Washington DC
and Melbourne
STATE SOVEREIGNTY AND
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
IN PAKISTAN: ANALYSING
THE REALISM STRANGLEHOLD
Ahmed Waqas Waheed
National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad, Pakistan
abstract In Pakistan, the field of international relations (IR) theory
remains firmly embedded in the ‘realist’ tradition, to the detriment
of a wider range of considerations. This stranglehold, strengthened
by the particular evolutionary trajectory of the Pakistani state as well
as a complacent academia, seems to have created a vicious circle of
knowledge reproduction, reinforced by various bids for power, or
proximity to it. This article scrutinises specifically the dominant
understandings in Pakistan of state sovereignty and security in a
broadly historical perspective, showing how the rise of the military,
combined with security paranoia, has prevented academic creativity
in this field, including scrutiny of recent concerns over rather close
China–Pakistan links.
keywords: academia, China–Pakistan relations, international
relations, military, Pakistan, security, sovereignty, state, Third World states
Introduction
After the present author had presented a paper at a local university on the state of
international relations (IR) in Pakistan, a senior academic queried: ‘Why do we need
any other theory when realism in its various manifestations answers all our questions?’
Precisely that is the problem. Most Pakistani academics find little or no utility in
developing or researching other IR theories and continue to fix their gaze on some
form of realism as an explanatory framework to analyse the country’s predicaments.
This article argues that the limited and restricted scope of IR theories in Pakistan has
as much to do with the country’s academia as with the evolution of the Pakistani state
and its deep-seated, almost paranoid concerns over sovereignty and security. Pakistan
is a state whose military has emerged as a powerful stakeholder in matters concerning
IR. This has, sometimes overtly and at other times covertly, captured and channelled