Dialysis, Albumin Binding, and Competitive Binding: A Laboratory
Lesson Relating Three Chemical Concepts to Healthcare
Jennifer P. Domingo,
†
Mohammed Abualia,
†
Diana Barragan,
†
Lianne Schroeder,
†
Donald J. Wink,
†
Maripat King,
‡
and Ginevra A. Clark*
,†
†
Department of Chemistry, University of Illinois, Chicago, MC-111, 845 W. Taylor Street, Chicago, Illinois 60607, United States
‡
College of Nursing, University of Illinois, Chicago, MC-802, 845 S. Damen Street, Chicago, Illinois 60612, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Introductory Chemistry laboratories must go beyond
“cookbook” methods to illustrate how chemistry concepts apply to
complex, real-world problems. In our case, we are preparing
students to use their chemistry knowledge in the healthcare
profession. The experiment described here explicitly models three
important chemical concepts: dialysis of small molecules (dye),
reversible binding (dye binding to albumin), and competitive
binding (dye and a competitor binding to albumin). Moreover, each
concept is intimately related to a physiological phenomenon:
dialysis is used to treat renal failure, drugs travel in the blood bound
to albumin, and competitive albumin binding is a common drug-
drug interaction. In the context of this simple series of experiments, students create models, use evidence to validate their models,
and finally use their understanding to describe physiological phenomena. This laboratory experiment was implemented in a 100-
level course for predominantly prenursing majors. Student pre- and postlab models were examined, illustrating an improved
conceptual understanding upon performing the lab and use of evidence to improve or support models. This experiment can be
performed in 1 h, and can be adapted as a lecture demonstration.
KEYWORDS: General Public, First Year Undergraduate/General, High School/Introductory Chemistry, Biochemistry,
Laboratory Instruction, Inquiry Based/Discovery Learning, Equilibrium, Membranes, Proteins/Peptides, Drugs/Pharmaceuticals
■
INTRODUCTION
In transforming the undergraduate curriculum to a more
student-centered approach, it is important to consider the goals
and interests of the students. Students preparing to enter
health-related fields may not understand how their chemistry
instruction is relevant to healthcare, or understand foundational
chemistry topics well enough to apply them. By developing
laboratories that illustrate biological systems, then asking
students to develop their own models and understandings,
we hope to bridge the gap between chemistry content
knowledge and student career interests.
This experiment models three concepts that have been
identified as foundational in nursing practice: dialysis, reversible
binding, and competitive binding. Several studies have surveyed
nursing faculty, students, and practitioners to identify concepts
that should be taught in chemistry courses.
1, 2
Dialysis
consistently ranks highly, yet few lessons have been developed
to clearly illustrate the concepts of dialysis,
3
or provide insight
for students as to why these concepts are relevant in healthcare.
This experiment provides a simple model for dialysis, which is
related to kidney function and several other processes in human
health. Further, in order for hydrophobic drugs to travel in the
bloodstream, they bind to the serum protein albumin.
4
In the
bound state, albumin acts as a reservoir; in the unbound state,
drugs are able to pass through small pores in the capillary and
reach their targets.
4
Finally, competitive albumin binding is a
common reason for drug-drug incompatibility. For example,
sulfonamide antibiotics should not be taken with blood
thinners, as competitive binding can alter the effective
concentration of either or both drugs in the bloodstream.
This can result in high effective concentrations of blood
thinner, which can contribute to major bleeding. In this
experiment, students perform dialysis of a dye molecule in the
presence or absence of albumin and in the presence of albumin
with a competitive binder in order to model these three
phenomena.
This lab is part of a series of laboratories we are developing
to teach fundamental concepts in chemistry that meet the
needs of prehealth students using the MORE framework.
5
The
curriculum is being developed with best practices in mind:
explicitly stating conceptual goals, including reflective prompts,
and allowing students time for discussion.
6
MORE, developed
by Rickey and co-workers,
7
asks students to model a system of
interest in both the macroscopic and molecular levels. In lab,
Received: February 17, 2017
Revised: May 16, 2017
Laboratory Experiment
pubs.acs.org/jchemeduc
© XXXX American Chemical Society and
Division of Chemical Education, Inc. A DOI: 10.1021/acs.jchemed.7b00131
J. Chem. Educ. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX