Review
How Americans make race: Stories, institutions
and spaces
Clarissa Hayward
Oxford University Press, New York, 2013, 212pp., $28.99 / £17.10,
ISBN: 1107619580
Contemporary Political Theory (2015) 14, e201–e204. doi:10.1057/cpt.2014.17;
published online 21 October 2014
Critics, commentators and scholars of racial inequality have come to face what is
becoming an increasingly thorny problem. On the one hand, empirics continue to
bear out the despairing variety of manifestations of racial inequality. Whether it
concerns income and job opportunity, access to health care, adverse interactions with
the law, or housing segregation (to name but a few), racial inequality is a rock-solid
fact of American social, political and economic life. In a positivist-minded country
that seems to live by the slogan ‘the numbers don’t lie’, one would think the entailing
moral arguments to then attend to racial inequality would be on safe ground. It is not
so. On the other hand of the facts there are the perceived norms: that racism is wrong,
and that blacks should have equal rights. And because these norms have themselves
also become, in a manner of speaking, facts of American life, one can sense that one
is losing his or her audience when race is cited as a causal factor in racial inequality.
Maybe more disappointingly, audience members turned interlocutors often move to
paint a coat of hysteria on the claim ‘it’s racial’, making the project of establishing
the racial quality of racial injustice inordinately difficult. There is a real need for work
that can demystify what is intended by the claim ‘it’s racial’ when referring to
inequality. Clarissa Hayward’s How Americans Make Race: Stories, Institutions, and
Spaces proves to be an important ally for critical commentators in demystifying what
is racial about at least one form of racial inequality – residential spaces – and
additionally it has the independent virtue of telling its own important story about the
false pretenses under which Americans continue to extol property-owning as a great
virtue.
As a good book title often does, Hayward’s gives us all the major markers we need
to grasp the vision of her book. Her central ambition is to describe and delineate for
readers the ways Americans have reified the category of race by telling or accepting
identity stories that have either infiltrated or originated in major institutions that
themselves have shaped America’s residential thus sociological landscape. The use
© 2015 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1470-8914 Contemporary Political Theory Vol. 14, 2, e201–e204
www.palgrave-journals.com/cpt/