Nonthermal-Plasma Reactions of Dilute Nitrogen Oxide Mixtures:
NO
x
-in-Argon and NO
x
+ CO-in-Argon
Xudong Hu, Gui-Bing Zhao, Ji-Jun Zhang, Linna Wang, and Maciej Radosz*
Department of Chemical & Petroleum Engineering, University of Wyoming, Laramie, Wyoming 82071-3295
Analysis of conversion mechanisms for NO and N
2
O in Ar plasma suggests that NO is converted
through the reaction Ar
+
+ NO + e
-
f Ar + N + O, whereas N
2
O is converted through the
reaction Ar
+
+ N
2
O + e
-
f Ar + N
2
+ O. A time-averaged lumped model developed on the basis
of this analysis matches the experimental data. CO inhibits N
2
O conversion but not NO
conversion. However, parts-per-million levels of CO affect neither N
2
O nor NO conversion.
Compared to N
2
plasma, which produces a weak streamer glow discharge and a small
temperature increase along the reactor, Ar plasma produces a strong streamer discharge and a
small temperature decrease along the reactor.
Introduction
Flue gas streams contain parts-per-million levels of
pollutants, such as NO
x
and SO
x
, that ideally are
removed or converted to benign species prior to dis-
charge. One way to convert NO
x
to nitrogen and oxygen
is to expose the flue gas stream to electric discharges
capable of generating radicals, ions, and excited mol-
ecules, which, in turn, activate the pollutants and
convert them to benign stable species. Such a reactive
mixture containing radicals, ions, and excited molecules
in an otherwise neutral gas is referred to as plasma. If
a potential difference is applied to plasma, the electric
field will impart energy to the charged particles. The
electrons, because of their small mass, will be im-
mediately accelerated to a higher degree between the
collisions than the heavier ions. If the pressure is low
or the electric field is high or both, the electrons and
the ions will, on average, have a kinetic energy higher
than the energy corresponding to the random motion
of the molecules. In plasma in such a state, usually
referred to as nonequilibrium plasma, the highly ener-
getic electrons are capable of ionizing and dissociating
the neutral species at high rates even though the bulk
gas temperature is quite low. Thus, it is said that such
“cold nonequilibrium” discharges are capable of high-
temperature chemistry at low temperatures. If, on the
other hand, the pressure is so high that the charged
particles do not move far between the collisions or the
electric field is weak or both, the kinetic energy of the
charged particles is not significantly different from the
kinetic energy of the neutral species. Such plasma is
called equilibrium plasma.
In this work, we use a reactor in which nonthermal,
nonequilibrium plasma is generated by a pulsed corona
reactor (PCR). A PCR converts dilute NO, NO
2
, and N
2
O
in nitrogen into the environmentally benign gases N
2
and O
2.
1-4
The electrons generated in a PCR collide with
the carrier gas and create chemically active species that
initiate NO
x
reactions. Although much experimental and
modeling work has been done on NO and N
2
O conver-
sion in a diatomic background gas, such as N
2
, little
work has been done on the conversion of NO
x
in a single-
atom background gas, such as Ar,
5,6
which produces
fewer active species. Thus, using argon as a background
gas might facilitate understanding of the chemical
reactions in a corona discharge reactor, especially
electron-molecule impact reactions.
An additional justification for exploring argon plasma
is that it has found a practical application in the
treatment of flue gas by a radical injection technique
as reported by Chang et al.
12
Their results showed a
very high rate of NO
x
destruction (85%) in the combus-
tion exhaust gas. Ohkubo et al.
25
used a small amount
of Ar introduced into the flue gas stream through the
corona discharging zone. Their results showed that the
corona discharge characteristics and modes are signifi-
cantly influenced by argon.
Such work requires kinetic models. An example of a
kinetic model is a time-averaged lumped model, initially
proposed by Hu et al.
6
and then improved by Zhao et
al.,
7
that was found to represent the NO, NO
2
, and N
2
O
concentration evolution in nitrogen. The primary goal
of this work is to extend this model to another type of
carrier gas, such as argon, also studied by Maier,
5
and
to test it on new experimental data taken in this work.
The secondary goal of this work is to understand the
effect of another minor component, such as CO, as an
example of a flue gas component that can alter the NO
x
conversion.
2,9
The NO
x
conversion study in this paper
refers to either NO or N
2
O conversion.
Experiment
The experimental apparatus and measurement pro-
cedures were described in detail previously.
8
In a brief
overview, the four-tube PCR used in this work consists
of a high-voltage power supply, a control unit, and a
pulser/reactor assembly. The high-voltage supply con-
trols the pulsed power delivered to the reactor. The
pulser/reactor assembly contains the pulsed power
generator and the pulsed corona discharge tubes. The
reactor has UV-grade quartz windows for diagnostics
and plasma observation. In all of the experiments
described in this work, only four of 10 tubes are wired
for plasma generation. The corona power is calculated
as the product of the pulse voltage (V) and current (I);
the energy is the time integral of power (∫VI dt). The
power consumed can also be calculated as the product
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:
radosz@uwyo.edu. Tel.: 307-766-2500. Fax: 307-766-6777.
7456 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2004, 43, 7456-7464
10.1021/ie0495731 CCC: $27.50 © 2004 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 10/12/2004