Abstract--Environmentally friendly technologies such as
photovoltaics and fuel cells are DC sources. In the current power
infrastructure, this necessitates converting the power supplied by
these devices into AC for transmission and distribution which
adds losses and complexity. The amount of DC loads in our
buildings is ever-increasing with computers, monitors, and other
electronics entering our workplaces and homes. This forces
another conversion of the AC power to DC, adding further losses
and complexity. This paper proposes the use of a DC distribution
system. In this study, an equivalent AC and DC distribution
system are compared in terms of efficiency.
Index Terms-DC power systems, power system modeling,
power distribution, losses
I. INTRODUCTION
ncreasing demand and environmental concerns have
forced engineers to focus on designing power systems
with both high efficiency and green technologies. Green
technologies are those that conserve natural resources such as
fossil fuels while reducing the human impact on the
environment through a reduction in pollution [1]. The most
well-known green technologies include photovoltaics and
wind turbines. Although fuel cells are not considered a green
technology, fuel cells have low emissions compared to other
forms of energy and are deemed more environmentally
friendly. Unfortunately, the prevailing power system
infrastructures are based on alternating current (AC) while
two of the leading environmentally friendly energies, fuel
cells and photovoltaics, produce direct current (DC).
Currently, power system infrastructures that wish to
incorporate fuel cells and photovoltaics must first convert the
DC power produced by these energy sources to AC. This adds
complexity and reduces efficiency of the power system due to
the need of a power converter. Furthermore, an ever
increasing number of DC consuming devices such as
computers, televisions, and monitors are being incorporated
into our buildings. The power supplied to these devices must
be converted again from AC back to DC adding further losses
and complexity to the power system.
Instead of using multiple converters to convert DC to AC
and then AC to DC, the power system could solely be based
on DC. This would eliminate the need for two sets of
converters for each DC load, reducing the cost, complexity,
and possibly increasing the efficiency. However, a definitive
analysis on a DC distribution system is needed to determine
the net benefits of eliminating the converters. In this paper, a
large steady state analysis of an existing AC grid is
constructed along with a DC counterpart. These models are
compared in terms of efficiency.
II. BACKGROUND
Since the development of electricity, AC has been depicted
as the better choice for power transmission and distribution.
However, Thomas Edison one of the founders of electricity
supported the use of DC. No method at that time existed for
boosting and controlling DC voltage at the load, so that
transmission of DC power from generation to load resulted in
a large amount of losses and voltage variations at the different
load locations. To resolve this issue, Westinghouse proposed
AC distribution. Nikola Tesla had only recently at that time
developed the transformer which had the capability of
boosting voltage in AC. This allowed for efficient
transmission of power from one location to another resulting
in a complete transformation of the power systems to AC [2].
Although many things have changed since the invention of
electricity, AC is still the fundamental power type of our
power infrastructure. However, due to the development of
power converters and DC energy sources, interest in DC has
returned.
Several studies have investigated the use of a DC
distribution system. In [3], a small-localized DC distribution
system for building loads is investigated. This power system
is supplied by a DC distributed energy source for the DC
loads and has a separate AC grid connection for the AC loads.
The author relates that this methodology leads to a higher
efficiency compared to a system solely based on AC through
avoiding the use of the rectifier. The author notes that power
rectifiers have a relatively low efficiency compared to
inverters and DC-DC converters.
In [4], a DC zonal distribution system for a Navy ship is
investigated to provide electrical isolation, reduce cost, and
increase stability. Essentially each zone has a separate
distribution system providing protection to the overall ship
power systems when an attack has occurred. Due to the need
of multiple levels of DC voltage, a DC system was deemed
superior to a AC system in terms of efficiency and cost. The
AC system would need an inverter and then DC-DC converter
for each DC bus voltage level, while a DC system would only
implement DC-DC converters.
AC vs. DC Distribution:
A Loss Comparison
Michael Starke
1
, Student Member, IEEE, Leon M. Tolbert
1,2
, Senior Member, IEEE,
Burak Ozpineci
2
, Senior Member, IEEE,
1
University of Tennessee,
2
Oak Ridge National Laboratory
I
978-1-4244-1904-3/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE