https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167218798823
Personality and Social
Psychology Bulletin
1–14
© 2018 by the Society for Personality
and Social Psychology, Inc
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/0146167218798823
pspb.sagepub.com
Empirical Research Paper
After staying up late to study, a tired student fails her organic
chemistry exam. At home, a tired man arguing with his wife
strikes her out of frustration. Late at night, an elderly woman
squanders her monthly paycheck playing blackjack in a
casino. On the surface, these events seem very different; how-
ever, they are all tied together through self-control. Self-
control is the process by which people alter their mental states
and behaviors to achieve desired goals in the face of goal-
opposing temptations or distractions. Being able to success-
fully enact self-control predicts a host of consequential
outcomes, including less propensity to drink alcohol in
excess, eat unhealthy foods, fight with romantic partners, and
neglect responsibilities (Crane, Testa, Derrick, & Leonard,
2014; Hofmann, Rauch, & Gawronski, 2007; Muraven,
Collins, Shiffman, & Paty, 2005; Simons, Wills, Emery, &
Spelman, 2016). Because self-control is so critical to many
important psychological processes, it is vital to identify fac-
tors that shape self-control, including physiological factors
such as sleep (Krizan & Hisler, 2016).
Growing evidence indicates that inadequate sleep leads to
self-control and these detrimental effects become especially
disconcerting when considering that large portions of chil-
dren and adults in the United States routinely fail to obtain
adequate sleep (Barnes & Drake, 2015; Barnes, Schaubroeck,
Huth, & Ghumman, 2011; Lanaj, Johnson, & Barnes, 2014).
Thus, understanding the influence of sleep on self-control is
also important for promoting optimal functioning and well-
being. To advance this understanding the current study used
data from a month-long daily diary to (a) replicate past find-
ings where less sleep the prior night leads to next-day self-
control difficulties, (b) examine a novel reason (i.e.,
perceived stress) for why short sleep leads to self-control dif-
ficulties, and (c) explore who may be more or less vulnerable
to this dynamic.
How Does Sleep Affect Self-Control?
One reason why insufficient sleep leads to self-control fail-
ures involves amplified difficulties in exerting control over
visceral and cognitive impulses. After a night of short or poor
sleep, people are less able to restrain undesirable urges, such
as stealing office supplies, cheating on tests, or insulting oth-
ers (Barnes, Lucianetti, Bhave, & Christian, 2015; Barnes et
798823PSP XX X 10.1177/0146167218798823Personality and Social Psychology BulletinHisler et al.
research-article 2018
1
Iowa State University, Ames, USA
2
Loyola University Chicago, IL, USA
Corresponding Author:
Garrett C. Hisler, Iowa State University, W014 Lagomarcino Hall, Ames,
IA 50014, USA.
Email: hislerg@iastate.edu
Does Stress Explain the Effect of Sleep on
Self-Control Difficulties? A Month-Long
Daily Diary Study
Garrett C. Hisler
1
, Zlatan Krizan
1
, and Tracy DeHart
2
Abstract
Insufficient sleep is linked to increased stress and suboptimal self-control; however, no studies have examined stress as
a reason for why sleep affects self-control. Moreover, it is unknown if there are individual differences that make people
vulnerable to this dynamic. Daily diary entries from 212 university students across 30 days were used in a multilevel path
model examining if stress explained how prior night sleep affected next-day self-control difficulties and exploring if individual
differences in sleep duration, stress, or self-control qualified this effect. Increased stress partially mediated of the effect of
reduced sleep duration on increased next-day self-control difficulty. Moreover, short sleep increased next-day stress more
for individuals with higher typical stress. Daytime stress especially amplified self-control difficulty for individuals with shorter
typical sleep duration. Findings implicate stress as a substantial factor in how sleep loss undermines self-control and identify
individuals particularly susceptible to this effect.
Keywords
sleep, self-control, stress, personality, diary
Received March 14, 2018; revision accepted August 13, 2018