SPINE Volume 31, Number 8, pp 909 –914
©2006, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Low Back Pain in Pediatric Athletes With Unilateral
Tracer Uptake at the Pars Interarticularis on Single
Photon Emission Computed Tomography
Masakazu Takemitsu, MD,*† Georges El Rassi, MD,* Patarawan Woratanarat, MD,*‡
and Suken A. Shah, MD*§
Study Design. Retrospective clinical study with radio-
graphic and medical chart review.
Objective. To study the clinical characteristics and out-
come of pediatric athletes with low back pain and unilat-
eral tracer uptake on single photon emission computed
tomography (SPECT) at the pars interarticularis but no
defect on radiographs.
Summary of Background Data. Some pediatric ath-
letes with low back pain have no findings on plain radio-
graphs but a unilateral SPECT uptake at the pars interar-
ticularis. However, little is known about these patients.
Methods. Twenty-two pediatric athletes who had low
back pain with increased tracer uptake on SPECT unilat-
erally at the pars interarticularis but no defect on plain
radiograph were evaluated. The following criteria were
used for evaluation: age, male-to-female ratio, duration of
symptoms, vertebral level, and presence of spina bifida
occulta or scoliosis.
Results. The average age was 12.3 2.5 years. The
male-to-female ratio was 1.2:1. The average duration of
symptoms was 21 23 weeks. Nineteen (86%) had in-
creased uptake at L5. Six (27%) had spina bifida occulta
and 8 (36%) had scoliosis. Eighteen (82%) patients
showed an excellent outcome. The patients who pre-
sented with a longer history of symptoms or a concomi-
tant spina bifida occulta had an increased risk of having
occasional aching with vigorous activity when compared
with the patients who did not (P 0.05).
Conclusions. Athletes who have low back pain and
increased tracer uptake unilaterally at the pars interarticu-
laris on SPECT are younger than those previously re-
ported patients with spondylolysis proven by a defect on
radiographs. Some of these lesions do progress to
“frank” spondylolysis seen on radiographs, but favorable
clinical outcomes from nonoperative treatment can be
expected. Patients with a longer pain history or concom-
itant spina bifida occulta may need careful follow-up
because they are at increased risk of having occasional
low back pain.
Key words: bone scintigraphy, low back pain, spina
bifida occulta, spondylolysis, stress reaction. Spine 2006;
31:909 –914
Low back pain is increasingly common in pediatric
athletes. The pain interferes with their performance
and may prevent them from playing sports. Spondylol-
ysis and spondylolisthesis are highly associated with
back pain in young athletes,
1–3
although there are ath-
letes who have asymptomatic spondylolysis or spon-
dylolisthesis. Micheli and Wood report that 47% of
adolescents with a chief complaint of low back pain
had spondylolysis,
4
whereas the incidence in the gen-
eral adult population was reported to be 5%.
5
A high
incidence of spondylolysis in athletes has also been
reported in specific sports including gymnastics,
6
weightlifting,
7
football,
8,9
swimming,
10
and diving.
7
The etiology of spondylolysis has been explained
mainly as an acquired stress fracture at the pars inter-
articularis resulting from repetitive flexion and exten-
sion motion of the lumbar spine.
11–15
Several authors address the importance of an early,
accurate diagnosis of spondylolysis with bone scintigra-
phy as leading to radiographic and clinical heal-
ing.
13,16,17
The sensitivity of detecting a stress reaction at
the pars is increased by the addition of single photon
emission computed tomography (SPECT).
18 –20
With the
advent of SPECT, pediatric athletes who complain of
low back pain and who have no pars defect on radio-
graphs but do have a unilateral stress reaction detected
by SPECT are seen frequently in the sports medicine
clinic. These patients are considered to have a prespon-
dylolysis; however, little has been documented about
them.
In this study, we focused on pediatric athletes with a
chief complaint of low back pain who presented with
unilateral increased uptake on SPECT but no pars defect
radiographically. Their clinical characteristics, including
age, male-to-female ratio, history of traumatic episode,
duration of symptoms, and incidence of spina bifida oc-
culta and scoliosis, were evaluated retrospectively. The
severity of their low back pain at follow-up was also
documented and analyzed for predictors that may affect
the clinical prognosis.
From the *Department of Orthopaedics, Nemours Children’s Clinic–
Wilmington, Alfred I. duPont Hospital for Children, Wilmington, DE;
†Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Asahikawa Medical College,
Asahikawa, Japan; ‡Department of Orthopaedics, Faculty of Medicine
Ramathibodi Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand; and §Department of
Orthopaedic Surgery, Jefferson Medical College, Philadelphia, PA.
Acknowledgment date: January 20, 2004. First revision date: May 9,
2004. Second revision date: May 26, 2005. Acceptance date: May 26,
2005.
The manuscript submitted does not contain information about medical
device(s)/drug(s).
No funds were received in support of this work. No benefits in any
form have been or will be received from a commercial party related
directly or indirectly to the subject of this manuscript.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Suken A. Shah, MD,
Alfred I. duPont Hospital for Children, Department of Orthopaedics,
1600 Rockland Road, PO Box 269, Wilmington, DE 19899. E-mail:
sshah@nemours.org
909