1 Copyright © 2013 by ASME
Proceedings of the ASME 2013 32nd International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering
OMAE2013
June 9-14, 2013, Nantes, France
OMAE2013-10814
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OF THE EFFECT OF WAVES, VENTILATION AND
CAVITATION IN BOLLARD PULL CONDITIONS
G. Hagesteijn
∗
Ships Department
MARIN
Wageningen, Netherlands
g.hagesteijn@marin.nl
J. Brouwer
Ships Department
MARIN
Wageningen, Netherlands
ABSTRACT
*
Ventilation is a feared working condition of ship
propulsors, especially in Dynamic Positioning operation, since
it leads to the lost of thrust of the propeller resulting into an
uncontrollable ship. Experience showed that the risk of
ventilating propellers was negligently underestimated in
traditional towing tank experiments but better predicted in
depressurised towing tanks, where the ambient pressure is
scaled down according to Froude similarity.
In 2012 MARIN’s Depressurized Wave Basin (DWB) has
taken into service. This unique facility is the only one in the
world that is able to generate waves in a large depressurized
towing tank. This ensures correct representation of the pressure
inside the enclosed ventilation bubbles and vortices, resulting
into a correct physic behaviour. The EU-funded Streamline
project was the first project for which ventilation inception
measurements were carried out in the DWB. Tests were carried
out with a fully instrumented podded ship model, sailing and in
bollard pull condition, in waves and depressurised conditions.
In order to acquire detailed load measurements, MARIN
used their in house developed 6 component and 5 component
transducers. The 6 component transducer was used for
measuring the omnidirectional propeller loads, while the 5
component transducer was used for measuring 2 blade forces
and 3 blade moments. At the same time synchronised high
speed video recordings were made to acquire insight in the
occurring phenomena. In the present paper a description of the
test set up will be presented briefly, followed by a discussion of
the recordings and the observations that were made for bollard
pull condition in waves.
*
Address all correspondence to this author
INTRODUCTION
When ventilation occurs unpredictably and uncontrolled,
the propeller starts racing due to the reducing torque in the
ventilated regime. This might cause severe damage to
traditional Diesel engines with at the same time imposing heavy
efficiency losses as at the higher RPM of a racing propeller; the
advance coefficient of the propeller is shifted into the
unfavourable off-design regime. One of the claimed advantages
of electric podded propulsion is that the electrical engines can
cope better with the dropping of torque, resulting in less engine
damages. On the other hand the loading of the propeller
bearings is more difficult to dimension due to the poor
knowledge available, in the public domain, on podded
propulsors in service or more specific, seakeeping conditions.
During higher sea states the propeller loading fluctuates
due to the variation in speed and the vertical motions of the
vessel, which will result in different cavitation behaviour and
inception speeds compared to the calm water conditions.
Moreover, based on past experiments in MARIN‘s Seakeeping
Basin, it was seen that ventilation can sometimes occur on pods
as well, a phenomenon which was observed to greatly affect
blade forces and moments, and thus the shaft loading as well.
The EU-funded Streamline project aimed at studying these
ventilation effects in detail.
WAVES IN DEPRESSURISED CONDITIONS
Experience [1] showed that the estimation of risk of
ventilating propellers in traditional model scale experiments
under atmospheric conditions varies from that of depressurized
conditions. Moreover, entrapped air pockets are proven to
behave differently at different scales [2]. Therefore, better