ARTICLE
Abstract and concrete repetitive thinking modes in alcohol-dependence
Delphine Grynberg, PhD
a
, Philippe de Timary
b,c,d
, Pierre Philippot
b
, Fabien D’Hondt, PhD
b
, Yasmine Briane
b
,
Faustine Devynck
e
,C eline Douilliez
e
, Jo€ el Billieux
b
, Alexandre Heeren, PhD
b,f
, and Pierre Maurage
b
a
University Lille, UMR 9193—SCALab—Sciences Cognitives et Sciences Affectives, Lille, France;
b
Laboratory for Experimental Psychopathology,
Psychological Sciences Research Institute, Universit e Catholique de Louvain, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium;
c
Saint-Luc Academic Hospital, Brussels,
Belgium;
d
Universit e Catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium;
e
University Lille, EA 4072—PSITEC—Psychologie: Interactions Temps
Emotions
Cognition, Lille, France;
f
Department of Psychology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA
ABSTRACT
Emotional and interpersonal deficits play a crucial role in alcohol-related disorders as they predict
alcohol consumption and relapse. Recent models of emotion regulation in psychopathology
postulate that these deficits are centrally related to increased abstract/analytic repetitive thinking,
combined with reduced concrete/experiential repetitive thinking. As this assumption has not been
tested in addictions, this study aimed at investigating repetitive thinking modes in a large sample of
alcohol-dependent subjects. One hundred recently detoxified alcohol-dependent subjects (29
females; mean age D 49.51-years-old) recruited during the 3rd week of their treatment in a
detoxification center were compared to 100 healthy controls (29 females; mean age D 48.51-years-
old) recruited in the experimenters’ social network, matched at the group level for age, gender, and
educational level. All participants completed the Mini Cambridge Exeter Repetitive Thought Scale
measuring abstract/analytic and concrete/experiential repetitive thinking modes as well as
complementary psychopathological measures (Beck Depression Inventory and State and Trait
Anxiety Inventory). Alcohol-dependent individuals have similar levels of concrete repetitive thinking
as controls but report significantly higher levels of abstract repetitive thinking (p < 0.001; d D 1.28).
This effect remains significant after controlling for depression and anxiety. Relative to healthy
controls, alcohol-dependent patients report more frequent use of abstract/analytic repetitive
thinking, with preserved concrete/experiential thinking. Despite the cross-sectional nature of the
study, frequent use of abstract repetitive thinking thus appears to constitute a main feature of
alcohol-dependence.
KEYWORDS
Alcohol-dependence;
repetitive thinking; abstract
thinking mode; concrete
thinking mode
Introduction
Alcohol-dependence is among the most widespread
psychiatric disorders worldwide,
1
leading to strongly
established cognitive deficits,
2
but also to a wide range
of emotional
3
and interpersonal impairments.
4
These
impairments should be considered as more than a
mere side-effect of alcohol-dependence as they consti-
tute one of the main relapse factors after mid-term
abstinence.
5
Moreover, as increased alcohol consump-
tion is conceptualized as a coping strategy to face
emotional and interpersonal difficulties,
5,6
these
deficits frequently initiate a vicious circle favoring the
development and maintenance of alcohol-related
disorders.
7
Beyond addiction, recent theoretical and
empirical models focusing on emotional and interper-
sonal deficits in psychopathology have pointed out
that these deficits are frequently related to a high-level
construal about self and mood (e.g., why a mood is
experienced) and to reduced concreteness of
thinking.
8,9
Indeed, two forms of repetitive thinking,
respectively named abstract/analytic [AA] and
concrete/experiential [CE], have been distinguished:
10
The AA repetitive thinking mode refers to the higher-
level causes, meanings and implications of self-experi-
ence. When confronted with adversity, this mode is
likely to engender negative overgeneralization (e.g., I
am always failing), known to increase the vulnerability
toward emotional deficits.
11
AA consists in general,
superordinate, and cross-situational thoughts which
make individuals apprehend a situation in terms of
“why” it occurred.
12
Conversely, CE repetitive think-
ing mode refers to lower-level, specific, contextual,
CONTACT Dr. Delphine Grynberg, PhD Delphine.Grynberg@univ-lille3.fr Domaine Universitaire du Pont de Bois, BP 149, Villeneuve d’Ascq 59653,
France.
© 2016 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
JOURNAL OF ADDICTIVE DISEASES
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10550887.2016.1207970