Delivered by Ingenta
IP : 83.142.52.87 On: Fri, 10 Apr 2020 10:47:07
Copyright The Policy Press
35
Journal of Psychosocial Studies • vol 13 • no 1 • 35–48 • © Policy Press 2020
Online ISSN 1478-6737 • https://doi.org/10.1332/147867320X15803492699268
SPECIAL ISSUE • The American tradition of psychosocial studies
article
Clad in mourning: psychoanalysis and race in
contemporary America
David W. McIvor, David.McIvor@colostate.edu
Colorado State University, USA
What is the value of psychoanalysis for the theorising of race in our contemporary moment?
This article explores this question by engaging with theories of Afropessimism, which criticise the
therapeutic ethic that traverses the wide variety of psychoanalytic approaches. Afropessimists
accuse psychoanalysis of perpetuating a racialised partition in the social order complicit with
‘anti-Blackness’. While stopping short of these conclusions, I argue that psychoanalysts and social
theorists need to countenance the possibilities that even their ‘race-conscious’ work might carry
assumptions that are ‘anti-Black’. In doing so I will argue that attempts to mourn the traumas and
losses associated with race have to fnd ways to account for the structural positioning of particular
racialised bodies.
Key words Afropessimism • Melanie Klein • mourning • melancholia • race
To cite this article: McIvor, D.W. (2020) Clad in mourning: psychoanalysis and race in
contemporary America, Journal of Psychosocial Studies, vol 13, no 1, 35–48,
DOI: 10.1332/147867320X15803492699268
I wanted to come lithe and young into a world that was ours and to help
build it together … yet my body was given back to me … clad in mourning.
(Fanon, 2008)
This article asks the question: What is the value of psychoanalysis for the theorising
of race in our contemporary moment – a moment when social awareness of systemic
racism is broader than ever, yet disturbing incidents of racial violence and vulnerability
persist alongside stubborn (if not intensifying) patterns of inequality and segregation?
The manic ‘post-racial’ moment that dawned with the election of Barack Obama in
2008 has shifted into a ‘most racial’ period of racialised political polarisation (Tesler,
2018). Continued patterns of precarity and abuse are scattered across the racial divide
in the United States (US), fuelling both novel social movements for change and
intellectual movements counselling pessimism and withdrawal. Can psychoanalysis
provide a conceptual framework or insights adequate for this situation?
As many scholars have pointed out, to develop psychoanalytic concepts for the
study of race can require reading into an absence, given the specifc lack of attention
to questions of racial identifcation or stigma in the foundational texts of Freud, Klein