A Study of Bone Mineral Density in Lower Limb Amputees
at a National Prosthetics Center
E
´
imear Smith, MD, MRCPI, Catherine Comiskey, PhD, A
´
ine Carroll, MD, MRCP, FRCPI, Nicola Ryall, FRCPI
ABSTRACT
The objective of this study was to examine the prevalence of low bone mineral density, based on World Health
Organization diagnostic criteria, in patients with lower limb amputation. This is a cross-sectional study of 52 lower limb
amputees in a national prosthetics center. All completed a questionnaire and had laboratory investigations and dual-
energy x-ray absorptiometry assessment of lumbar spine and both hips. Study participants were 24 transtibial amputees
(46.2%), 19 (36.5%) transfemoral amputees, 8 (15.4%) bilateral amputees, and 1 (1.9%) with a hip disarticulation. Six
(11.5%) were unable to walk at all, 26 (50%) were only indoor walkers, and 20 (38.5%) were outdoor walkers. Thirty-three
patients (68.8%) were vitamin D deficient, 25-hydroxyvitamin D level less than 50 nmol/L, and five (10.4%) had
insufficiency, level between 50 and 72 nmol/L. Based on T-scores, 26 (50%) had osteopenia and 20 (38.5%) had
osteoporosis at either lumbar spine or hip. Z-score -1 but -2 occurred in 25 (48.1%), and Z-score -2 occurred
in 10 (19.2%) at a minimum of one site. Negative correlation was found between duration of disability and bone mineral
density (BMD) at the neck of femur (r =-0.447, p = 0.002) and total proximal femur (r =-0.391, p = 0.009) on the
amputated side. There was a significant difference between BMD of the sound and amputated sides at the neck of femur
(t = 6.17, df = 43, p 0.001) and total proximal femur (t = 7.79, df = 43, p 0.001). BMD was not affected by
amputation level or ambulatory status. Osteopenia and osteoporosis occur frequently in lower limb amputees. Hip BMD
on the amputated side is correlated with duration since amputation. Bone health monitoring should form part of the
long-term follow-up in this patient population. (J Prosthet Orthot. 2011;23:14 –20.)
KEY INDEXING TERMS: osteoporosis, bone mineral density, lower limb amputation, dual energy x-ray
A
mong lower limb amputees, 52.4% have reported at
least one fall in the previous year.
1
Therefore, it is
surprising that lower limb fracture rates in this pop-
ulation have been reported at just 2.35% and 3%, although
these recordings were taken more than 20 years ago when life
expectancy after amputation was possibly shorter than it is
now.
2,3
It was suggested in one of these publications that
fracture rate was likely to increase among amputees with
improving life expectancy among dysvascular patients.
3
There are reports of a decline in bone mineral density (BMD)
at the hip of the amputated limb. This was initially suspected
on plain x-rays
4,5
and later confirmed by dual-energy x-ray
absorptiometry (DXA).
6
On the amputated limb, BMD has
been reported to be an average of 10.4% to 12% less than the
sound side, greater trochanter 14.9% less, and proximal tibia
45% less.
7–9
When comparisons were drawn between BMD on
the amputated side and controls, the mean differences at the
neck of femur ranged between 10% and 28%, at the greater
trochanter 8.8%, and at the proximal tibia 24%.
7–9
It was also
observed that the reduction in femoral neck BMD was signif-
icantly greater in transfemoral than in transtibial amputees.
6
After fracture, a decline in mobility status has been re-
ported in this patient population.
2,3,10
In a population with
such a high rate of falls and significantly lower BMD at the
hip of the amputated leg, fracture prevention should form a
part of long-term medical follow-up. Fracture prevention first
entails finding patients who are at risk of fracture. BMD
measurement using DXA at any specific site is the single best
predictor of fracture at that site and provides the measures on
which World Health Organization (WHO) diagnostic catego-
ries are based; the hip represents the site with greatest
predictive power.
11
In calculating fracture risk based on
BMD, actual BMD measurements (gram per square centime-
ter) are expressed as relative values, T-score, and Z-score,
T-score representing a comparison with the young adult
reference mean and Z-score representing a comparison with
the age-matched mean. According to WHO criteria, a T-score
of less than or equal to 1 standard deviation (SD) below the
young adult mean is normal, a T-score greater than 1 but less
than 2.5 SD below the young adult mean is osteopenia, and a
T-score of 2.5 or more SD below the young adult mean is
classified as osteoporosis. Every SD in BMD below the age-
matched mean correlates to an approximate doubling of
fracture risk, a relationship best proven in postmenopausal
women and men older than 50 years.
11–14
To date, there is no
E
´
IMEAR SMITH, MD, MRCPI, A
´
INE CARROLL, MD, MRCP, FRCPI,
AND NICOLA RYALL, FRCPI, are affiliated with the Department of
Rehabilitation Medicine, National Rehabilitation Hospital, Du ´n
Laoghaire, Dublin, Ireland.
CATHERINE COMISKEY, PhD, is affiliated with the School of Nurs-
ing and Midwifery, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Disclosure: The authors declare no conflict of interest.
This work was supported by the National Medical Rehabilitation
Trust Ltd. (Ireland).
Copyright © 2010 American Academy of Orthotists and Prosthetists.
Correspondence to: E
´
imear Smith, MD, MRCPI, Department of
Rehabilitation Medicine, National Rehabilitation Hospital, Roch-
estown Avenue, Du ´ n Laoghaire, Dublin, Ireland; e-mail: eimear.
smith@nrh.ie
14 Volume 23 • Number 1 • 2011