Abstract Citrus phylogeny was investigated using
RAPD, SCAR and cpDNA markers. The genotypes ana-
lyzed included 36 accessions belonging to Citrus to-
gether with 1 accession from each of the related genera
Poncirus, Fortunella, Microcitrus and Eremocitrus.
Phylogenetic analysis with 262 RAPDs and 14 SCARs
indicated that Fortunella is phylogenetically close to
Citrus while the other three related genera are distant
from Citrus and from each other. Within Citrus, the sep-
aration into two subgenera, Citrus and Papeda, desig-
nated by Swingle, was clearly observed except for C.
celebica and C. indica. Almost all the accessions be-
longing to subgenus Citrus fell into three clusters, each
including 1 genotype that was considered to be a true
species. Different phylogenetic relationships were re-
vealed with cpDNA data. Citrus genotypes were sepa-
rated into subgenera Archicitrus and Metacitrus, as pro-
posed by Tanaka, while the division of subgenera Citrus
and Papeda disappeared. C. medica and C. indica were
quite distant from other citrus as well from related gen-
era. C. ichangensis appeared to be the ancestor of the
mandarin cluster, including C. tachibana. Lemon and
Palestine sweet lime were clustered into the Pummelo
cluster led by C. latipes. C. aurantifolia was located in
the Micrantha cluster. Furthermore, genetic origin was
studied on 17 cultivated citrus genotypes by the same
molecular markers, and a hybrid origin was hypothe-
sized for all the tested genotypes. The assumptions are
discussed with respect to previous studies; similar re-
sults were obtained for the origin of orange and grape-
fruit. Hybrids of citron and sour orange were assumed
for lemon, Palestine sweet lime, bergamot and Volkamer
lemon, while a citron × mandarin hybrid was assumed
for Rangpur lime and Rough lemon. For Mexican lime
our molecular data indicated C. micrantha to be the fe-
male parent and C. medica as the male one.
Key words Citrus · RAPD · SCAR · cpDNA ·
Phylogeny · Origin
Introduction
Different hypotheses have been formulated on the origin
of Citrus. In general, Citrus is believed to have originat-
ed in the tropical and subtropical regions of Southeast
Asia and then spread to other continents (Webber 1967;
Calabrese 1992). Citrus taxonomy and phylogeny, how-
ever, are very complicated, controversial and confusing,
mainly due to sexual compatibility between Citrus and
related genera, the high frequency of bud mutations and
the long history of cultivation and wide dispersion.
In the past, studies on relationships between genera
and species were carried out based mainly on morpho-
logical characteristics. Numerous classification systems
have been formulated, among which those of Swingle
(1943) and Tanaka (1977) have been the most widely ac-
cepted. Even these two researchers, however, have quite
different concepts with respect to species classification,
as Swingle included only 16 species in Citrus while
Tanaka described 162. Later phylogenetic analysis by
Scora (1975) and Barrett and Rhodes (1976) suggested
that there were only 3 true species within the cultivated
Citrus, i.e. citron (Citrus medica L.), mandarin (C. reti-
culata Blanco) and pummelo [C. grandis (L.) Osb.] (in
1988 Scora added another true species: C. halimii
Stone). The other genotypes were derived from hybrid-
ization between these true species. More recently, this
concept has gained further support from various studies
using biochemical and molecular markers, including iso-
zymes (Torres et al. 1978; Fang et al. 1993; Herrero et al.
1996), organeller genome analysis (Green et al. 1986;
Yamamoto et al. 1993) and microsatellites (Fang and
Roose 1997; Fang et al. 1998).
Communicated by P.M.A. Tigerstedt
E. Nicolosi (
✉
) · Z.N. Deng · A. Gentile · S. La Malfa
G. Continella · E. Tribulato
Istituto di Coltivazioni arboree, University of Catania,
Via Valdisavoia, 5, 95123 Catania, Italy
Fax: +39-095-356322
e-mail: nicoeli@mbox.fagr.unict.it
Theor Appl Genet (2000) 100:1155–1166 © Springer-Verlag 2000
ORIGINAL PAPER
E. Nicolosi · Z.N. Deng · A. Gentile · S. La Malfa
G. Continella · E. Tribulato
Citrus phylogeny and genetic origin of important species
as investigated by molecular markers
Received: 5 October 1999 / Accepted: 3 November 1999