104
EMERGENCE, 2(4), 104–112
Copyright © 2000, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Knowledge as Action,
Organization as Theory:
Reflections on Organizational Knowledge
Haridimos Tsoukas
If you desire to see, learn how to act
Reality = community
Heinz von Foerster (1984)
G
overnment officials in the UK recently conducted an
inspection of the teaching methods and aims of
Summerhill, an independent school well known for its
libertarian philosophy. In their report, the inspectors
charged the school with lack of discipline and clear structures, and were
categorical that Summerhill’s modus operandi leaves its students inade-
quately prepared for the rigors of life after school. Reacting to the report,
several supporters of Summerhill claimed the reverse. The school’s
libertarian philosophy, they said, gives students what conventional
schools fail to give: freedom to explore themselves and find out what
they are good at.
This episode (and several others like it) is interesting because the
same set of activities (teaching and school management) is assessed so dif-
ferently by two different observers. What differentiates the observers is
that they use different assessment criteria, derived from different
domains of action. The inspectors do exactly what they are supposed to
do: ensure that schools broadly conform to a set of criteria defined by the
government. Summerhill supporters, on the contrary, subscribe to an