Journal of critical reviews 1586
Journal of Critical Reviews
ISSN- 2394-5125 Vol 7, Issue 8, 2020
TOWARDS EMPOWERING ZAKAT RECIPIENTS: AN ASSESSMENT ON EFFECTIVENESS
OF ZAKAT INSTITUTIONS FROM THE ZAKAT RECIPIENTS’ PERSPECTIVE
Norazlina Abd Wahab
1
, Md Mahmudul Alam
2
, Ashraf Al Haq
3
, Suraiya Hashim
4
, Zairy Zainol
5
1,3,4,5
Islamic Business School, Universiti Utara Malaysia
2
School of Economics, Finance and Banking, Universiti Utara Malaysia
Received: 20.05.2020 Revised: 17.06.2020 Accepted: 04.07.2020
Abstract
This study aims to investigate the effectiveness of zakat institutions from the zakat recipients’ perspective. Researchers opine that
empowering is a matter of utmost importance in order to ensure recipients are self-sufficient, self-reliant and can withstand any
hardship come it may. Therefore the zakat authorities need to safeguard a robust empowerment regime and for that reason the
assessment of that performance may require a newer dimensional approach where ‘the recipients’ who are the main stakeholders do
evaluate the contributory performative assessment through the main four perspectives as enshrined by the Balanced Scorecard
technique which include financial effectiveness, customer effectiveness, internal effectiveness and learning & growth effectiveness.
Hence, the goal is to investigate the effectiveness of zakat institutions of Kedah, Malaysia in particular. A total of 427 responses received,
where Partial Least Squares approach was employed as the main data analysis of this study. The research identified that all the four
components are interlinked and need a coherent addressing in terms of zakat recipients’ upliftment . The recipients did put emphasis on
the priority of the financial effectiveness, but in a non-profit environment where the customer effectiveness is vital, may require the
service enhancement along with putting the emphasis on learning and making certain systematic rejuvenation of the processes, as well
as the planned financial decision to make effects conducive to empowerment of the recipients.
Keyword-- Balanced Scorecard, Effectiveness, Empowerment, Zakat, Zakat institution
© 2020 by Advance Scientific Research. This is an open-access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.31838/jcr.07.08.313
INTRODUCTION
In the drive towards empowerment of zakat recipients, the
current emphasis is rather on action than mere words.
Furthermore, the literature in its development is very wide and
but marginally debatable. The reason is, since very beginning the
researchers did identify the important gap of ‘empowerment’
that has been unknowingly missing in general zakat giving, but
lately many recent authors proclaiming that ‘it’ is on the move,
but the ground reality is, it is still bit not that supportive to
asnafs’ (zakat recipients) overall condition as well as drive
towards genuine upliftment and sustainable welfare. Therefore, a
need arises to understand the reality in true sense and hence the
present research aims to assess and understand the recipients’
perspective in drive towards empowering them, where their
valued inputs will determine the magnitude of the true
development in the empowerment arena. It is intended to
understand as well as appreciate the zakat’s institutional
development and performance through the understanding of the
wellbeing issue of the zakat recipients, and if the issue is well
addressed and the wellbeing ‘is’ noticeable – only then it will
nonetheless indicate that the institutional performance is well
adhered, and the institutions are responding to the needs and
wellbeing of the recipients.
Bakar et al. (2011) though posit that the self-sustaining, self-
empowering method of zakat management could be most
effective for the asnaf development, but before embarking on
that noble mission, the authors such as Ahmad et al. (2017)
acknowledge the missing gaps of customer service satisfaction in
zakat management. The authors highlighted the importance of
zakat’s service provision that are necessary in reducing the
inequality, and increasing the ability, through capacity building,
as visualised by Ab Rahman et al. (2012).
In addition to customer satisfaction, the importance of financial
dimension is equally significant. The authors (Ahmad et al.,
2017), states that zakat has the potential of having strategic
importance in the world of ‘Islamic finance’ and is rated as the
most ‘critical instrument’ in a developing economy, which in
other words to purify and sanctify one’s wealth (Al Qur’an
9:103), that can help in societal development through the
proactive and effective empowering assistance. The process in
retrospect assists in reducing the income inequality gaps over
time to a significant extent that exists in society.
Thirdly the internal development dimension is equally
paramount in ensuring unhindered empowerment in the drive
towards the recipients’ welfare. In Ahmad et al. (2017)
explanation, empowerment through zakat, can supplement and
enhance the comfortable living in broader sense. Because the
benefits of effective management (internal development), will
enhance service quality, and that in turn will broaden the
collection, distribution and beyond - to soothe the relationship as
well, between the haves and the have-nots. In actual fact,
ensuring the wellbeing of the recipients, does make in-depth
sense in effective giving, and that as well is in conformity with
Maslow’s theory of human development (Bakar et al., 2011).
But above all, the skills development and knowledge
enhancement in empowerment strategy would make the
recipients become more up-to-mark to combat poverty directly
and be resilient in dimensional change. Ab Rahman et al. (2012)
explains in plain terms that though short-term cash hand-outs
are important for subsistence, but focusing on long-term
empowerment and skills enhancement is vital for proactive and
effective economic development and growth in the nation. In
same breath, Yusoff (2008) emphasised the need for
implementing the long term policy approach along with the
shorter one. According to the said author there is dire need to
educate the receivers in line with human capital development so
that these zakat receivers can have self-sustaining development
in the longer run. Though there are asnafs who will be in
continuous need bracket due to health or age issues, but the vast
majority must be reoriented so as to survive through new skills