Send Orders of Reprints at bspsaif@emirates.net.ae
22 Combinatorial Chemistry & High Throughput Screening, 2013, 16, 22-31
Assessing and Comparing the Total Antioxidant Capacity of Commercial
Beverages: Application to Beers, Wines, Waters and Soft Drinks Using
TRAP, TEAC and FRAP Methods
Raquel B. Queirós
1,2
, Paula A.R. Tafulo
2
and M. Goreti F. Sales
*,1
1
BioMark/ISEP, School of Engineering, Polytechnic Institute, R. Dr. António Bernardino de Almeida, 431, 4200-072
Porto, Portugal
2
INESC Tec (coordinated by INESC Porto) and Faculty of Sciences, University of Porto, Rua do Campo Alegre, 687,
4150-179 Porto, Portugal
Abstract: This work measures and tries to compare the Antioxidant Capacity (AC) of 50 commercial beverages of
different kinds: 6 wines, 12 beers, 18 soft drinks and 14 flavoured waters. Because there is no reference procedure
established for this purpose, three different optical methods were used to analyse these samples: Total Radical trapping
Antioxidant Parameter (TRAP), Trolox Equivalent Antioxidant Capacity (TEAC) and Ferric ion Reducing Antioxidant
Parameter (FRAP). These methods differ on the chemical background and nature of redox system. The TRAP method
involves the transfer of hydrogen atoms while TEAC and FRAP involves electron transfer reactions. The AC was also
assessed against three antioxidants of reference, Ascorbic acid (AA), Gallic acid (GA) and 6-hydroxy-2,5,7,8-tetramethyl-
2-carboxylic acid (Trolox).
The results obtained were analyzed statistically. Anova one-way tests were applied to all results and suggested that
methods and standards exhibited significant statistical differences. The possible effect of sample features in the AC, such
as gas, flavours, food colouring, sweeteners, acidity regulators, preservatives, stabilizers, vitamins, juice percentage,
alcohol percentage, antioxidants and the colour was also investigated. The AC levels seemed to change with brand, kind
of antioxidants added, and kind of flavour, depending on the sample. In general, higher ACs were obtained for FRAP as
method, and beer for kind of sample, and the standard expressing the smaller AC values was GA.
Keywords: Antioxidant capacity, beer, beverages, FRAP, soft drinks, TEAC, TRAP, water, wine.
1. INTRODUCTION
Humans cannot exist without oxygen but oxygen is
intrinsically dangerous to their existence. The major
production of ATP in the cell is an oxygen dependent
process, carried out in the mitochondria via the electron
transport chain. It involves the oxidation of energy-rich
molecules and the transfer to oxygen (O
2
) of the redox power
in NADH and FADH
2
, produced in several steps. This
univalent reduction of oxygen generates reactive
intermediates, including the superoxide anion radical,
hydrogen peroxide and the extremely reactive hydroxyl
radical. These seem to be the main responsible for oxygen
toxicity [1-3].
The defense network in vivo against these radicals [4]
includes various antioxidants (AOs). Some are proteins and
enzymes, while others are small molecules [5]. They may act
as (i) preventing antioxidants by suppressing the formation
of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, (ii) scavenging
antioxidants by removing active species rapidly before the
active species attack biologically essential molecules, and
(iii) by repairing damages (de novo antioxidants), clearing
the wastes, and reconstituting the lost function [6]. A body
*Address correspondence to this author at the BioMark/Instituto Superior de
Engenharia do Porto, R. Dr. António Bernardino de Almeida, 431, 4200-072
Porto, Portugal; Tel: +351 228 340 500; Fax: +351 228 321 159;
E-mails: goreti.sales@gmail.com, mgf@isep.ipp.pt
deficiency in these AOs can lead to oxidative stress and,
subsequently to the oxidation of biomolecules [3, 7],
accelerating the aging process and contributing to the
development of chronic degenerative diseases, including
coronary heart disease and cancer [2, 3, 7-10]. Exogenous
AOs intake can play a crucial role in body protection against
such diseases [11], as suggested by epidemiological data
[12].
Foods obtained from plant processing methods constitute
an important source of dietary AOs [13-15], with great
emphasis for polyphenol compounds [16]. These include
daily beverages such as wines, beers, soft-drinks, flavored
waters, and juices. Some advantages coming from drinking
these have also been highlighted in the literature. Drinking
wine moderately may help preventing cardiovascular
diseases and some types of cancers [3, 17-21]. This has been
associated to the high levels of polyphenols in wines,
because they act as free radical-scavenging compounds,
participating in the second line defense in vivo [6]. A similar
condition was attributed to beer, although with lower levels
of polyphenols [22-24]. Drinks derived from fruits and
vegetables are also rich in polyphenolic compounds [25-27],
although less biologically available than in wines because
they are strongly bonded. In addition to their AO activity,
dietary AO are thought to have several beneficial activities
by behaving as antibacterial and antiviral agents [28].
1875-5402/13 $58.00+.00 © 2013 Bentham Science Publishers