Business, Management and Economics
Research
ISSN(e): 2412-1770, ISSN(p): 2413-855X
Vol. 1, No. 8, pp: 107-118, 2015
URL: http://arpgweb.com/?ic=journal&journal=8&info=aims
*Corresponding Author
107
Academic Research Publishing Group
Consultants as Strategic Practitioners: An Analysis in the
Sociological Field Research of Strategy-as-Practice
Renato Lopes da Costa
*
ISCTE: Lisbon, Portugal
Nelson Antonio
ISCTE: Lisbon, Portugal
Isabel Miguel
ISLA: Santarém, Portugal
1. Introduction
In fact, although the strategic management consulting activities have achieved considerable growth in terms of
economic significance in recent years, these findings have not been properly accompanied by a greater number of
conceptual and empirical researches, resulting in a shortage of insight about the effective work of the consultants
(Fincham and Clark, 2002a).
In Portugal, although some studies such as the ones of Ferreira and Peixoto (1992), InĂ¡cio and Weir (1993),
Amorim (1999), Amorim and Kipping (1999), Silva (1997) and Freire (2008), have contributed in some way to the
construction of scientific knowledge in this area, the truth is that none of them focuses on the study of practices and
activities at the level of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Portugal.
Internationally, although the progress and the heterogeneity of scientific studies carried out over the past decade
in the area of strategic consulting for prestigious authors such as Sturdy (1997), Sturdy and Wright (2008), Sturdy
(2009), Kaiser and Kampe (2005), McGivern (1983), McLarty and Robinson (1998), Fincham (1999), (Fincham and
Clark, 2002a), (Fincham et al., 2008) (Karantinou and Hogg, 2001;2009), Werr and Linnarsson (2002), Werr and
Styhre (2002), Jackall (1988), Clark (1995), Clark and Salaman (1996), Clark (2004), (Jarzabkowski, 2004;2005),
Jarzabkowski et al. (2007), Jarzabkowski and Spee (2009), Jarzabkowski (2003), (Whittington, 2001;2002;
Whittington et al., 2004; Whittington, 2006;2007) and Lundgren and Blom (2009) are synonymous of added value,
the fact is retained is that also here the strategy workers hev not received much attention in the strategic field of
research. Whittington (2007) gives us an example of this, by stressing out that until 2007 there were no articles
published about consulting in one of the main strategy newspapers like the "Strategy Management Journal". A
deeper and more recent research also shows there are no publications within the research field of strategy-as-practice
and under the link of this area to the work of strategic consultants.
On a more practical component, even though the recent move of the Strategy-as-Practice
1
(SAP) have implied
some attention on the importance of consultants (Jarzabkowski et al., 2007; Jarzabkowski and Spee, 2009;
1
Movement created in 2007 by Whittington and Jarzabkowski through www.strategy_as_pratice.org internet site in order to
understand the actions, interactions and multi-stakeholder negotiations to build a set of practical situations that result later in a
particular activity, bringing to the center of the study actions and interactions in the field of strategic research and the research
field of social complexity and causal ambiguity of the basic view of resource analysis, which comes to explain the practice that
constitutes the strategic process
Abstract: Although management consulting activities have obtained a considerable growth in terms of
economic significance in recent years, these results have not been duly followed by a greater number of
conceptual and empirical researches in this area. In order to fight the lack of studies on the actual work of
management consultants, this article aims at answer to one question that remains open. Are consultants the real
experts and the true practitioners of strategy as practice? The results of the empirical analysis in the form of semi-
structured interviews and questionnaires given to management consultants and SME managers in Portugal shows
that management consulting is founded on a knowledge-intensive base, although consultants cannot be called
strategy practitioners as many authors call them. This is illustrated in the model presented in this article, which
means this proposition is a new direction in strategic thinking in what the field's research strategy-as-practice
concerns.
Keywords: Management consulting; Strategy-as-practice; Knowledge.