European J. International Management, Vol. 7, No. 5, 2013 501
Copyright © 2013 Inderscience Enterprises Ltd.
An exploration of two perspectives on leadership
in globalised contexts
Rune Rønning*, Bjarne Espedal and
Atle Jordahl
NHH – The Norwegian School of Economics,
Breviksveien 40, 5041 Bergen, Norway
Email: rune.roenning@aff.no
Email: bjarne.espedahl@nhh.no
Email: atle.jordahl@aff.no
*Corresponding author
Abstract: This paper explores two models of leadership in the globalised
context, one rooted in instrumentality and the other in appropriateness. While
the logic of instrumentality assumes that leadership practices are universal
across national and institutional borders, the logic of appropriateness is
sensitive to cross-national cultural and institutional differences. These
two standpoints and their relation to multinational enterprises (MNEs) are
traced in organisational global leadership theory. Ultimately, the consequences
of implementing either of these two thought processes while designing
leadership development programs are identified. We argue that applying the
logic of instrumentality uncritically to leadership in the globalised context of
multinational enterprises is fraught with great risk because this logic tends to
ignore the diversity and complexity of MNEs and their environments. It is
suggested that the logic of appropriateness in leadership constitutes a viable,
suitable and complementary alternative.
Keywords: leadership; global leadership; globalised contexts; institutional
theory; international management.
Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Rønning, R., Espedal, B.
and Jordahl, A. (2013) ‘An exploration of two perspectives on leadership in
globalised contexts’, European J. International Management, Vol. 7, No. 5,
pp.501–516.
Biographical notes: Rune Rønning is the R&D Director of The Administrative
Research Institute at The Norwegian School of Economics in Bergen, Norway.
He holds the degree of DMan from University of Hertfordshire, UK, and his
primary education is as a clinical psychologist. He has a worked as a consultant
within organisational psychology for close to 30 years, and as a researcher
within the field of social capital and organisation development as well as
gender balance. At present he leads a nationwide research project on
Norwegian managers.
Bjarne Espedal is Professor of Leadership and Organisational Theory at NHH –
The Norwegian School of Economics in Bergen, Norway. His research
interests are concentrated on organisational learning and change. He has
published numerous articles in journals such as Human Resource Management,
British Journal of Management, Journal of Applied Behavioral Science,
Leadership, Journal of Organizational Change Management, Journal of