978-1-5386-0517-2/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE.
Network Resonance Detection using Harmonic
Active Power
Agknaton Bottenberg
1
,Colin Debruyne
1, 3
, Brandon Peterson
2
, Johan Rens
2
, Jos Knockaert
1
, Jan Desmet
1
1
Electrical Energy Laboratory, Ghent University, Sint-Pietersnieuwstraat 41, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium
2
School for Electronic and Electrical Engineering, North-West University (NWU) Potchefstroom Campus, X6001
Potchefstroom, 2520 South Africa
3
Advices for Technical Systems div. Power Quality, Karel De Roosestraat 15, B-9820 Merelbeke, Belgium
Abstract—Resonances in electrical distribution systems can
result in amplification of harmonics, which is undesirable in
electrical networks. To avoid intrusive measurement techniques,
in the majority of the cases network modeling is used to
validate if there is an issue with resonance. In this paper a new,
innovative but simple, concept is presented which uses relatively
basic measurements to segregate the power related to specific
harmonics into active and non-active harmonic power. These
results are subsequently used in order to find if there is resonance
in the electrical network. In this paper the concepts are explained
on a theoretical basis and are test cased by numerical modeling.
The initial results look promising but additional research is
needed to validate the method.
I. I NTRODUCTION
With the increased penetration of power electronics,
both from electrical loads and generators, the network is
additionally strained with harmonic content. When focussing
on the problems related to harmonics in networks, they
negatively affect the life expectancy of the insulation in
the network, generate additional losses in transformers
and might damage active capacitor banks [1]–[3]. Because
networks consists of inductances, capacitance and some
resistance, there is always resonance in the network. Practical
problems arise at the moment the resonance amplifies the
distortion in either voltage or current. Therefore it is of
great concern to determine the network’s impedance over
frequency characteristic to evaluate if there is an issue related
to harmonic resonance. In the majority of the cases this is
estimated at the design stage of the network and done via
modeling in dedicated software.
In situ monitoring of those impedance over frequency plots
is essential for stable operation, but this generally requires
intrusive methods. There have been some suggestions of
algorithms to try to obtain this data based on measurements
using non-intrusive techniques [4], [5]. This proves to be
promising, although the long iterative process requires a lot
of time. In a practical setting the previous methods are facing
practical disadvantages as the network’s impedance is varying
due to switching actions and reconfiguration of the network
by the network operator. In this paper a basic measurement
method is suggested to perform a real time detection of
resonance phenomena in the network based on the power
related to individual harmonics. The basic concept, including
its limitations, is mathematically explained in §II and §III.
Subsequently, this method is used in a numerical model to
testcase the validity §IV and the results validate the suggested
method.
Although the results of the modeling indicate that the
proposed method has potential, this method does also has
constraints. As will be addressed in the paper, the suggested
method can bridge the gap to the more complex analysis of
the prevailing harmonic phase angle, however this research is
specifically focussed on finding a very basic, low level, method
for an indication of resonance. As will be discussed in §V,
much more validation is needed.
II. BASIC ANALYSIS OF RESONANCE PHENOMENA
In electrical systems, there is a resonance if the reactive
power component in the inductor is equal and opposite to the
reactive power component in the capacitor. When written in
terms of reactances, resonance occurs if:
X
l
= X
c
(1)
With X
l
the inductive reactance and X
c
the capacitive re-
actance. For electrical distribution systems the reactance is
depending on the frequency, so resonance occurs for specific
resonance frequencies f
r
in which:
f
r
=
1
2.π.
√
L.C
(2)
With L the inductance in [H] and C the capacity in [F]. Two
types of resonance can occur, namely parallel resonance and
series resonance.
Fig. 1. [A] Parallell resonance with ESR, [B] Series Resonance
In case of parallel resonance the impedance goes from zero
to -theoretically- infinite, and then back to zero. Subsequently,
in case of series resonance, the impedance goes from highly