1233
0361-803X/95/1 655-1 233
© American Roentgen Ray Society
Evaluation of Normal and
Abnormal Lips in Fetuses: Comparison
Between Three- and Two-Dimensional
Sonography
Dolores H. Pretorius1
Michael House1
Thomas R. Nelson1
Kathryn A. Hollenbach2
OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to determine if three-dimensional (3D)
sonography could improve prenatal evaluation of fetal lips in comparison with con-
ventional two-dimensional (2D) sonography.
MATERIALS AND METHODS. Sixty-one high-risk pregnant women and 10 low-risk
pregnant women were examined with conventional 2D sonography followed by 3D
sonography with a volume transducer. The ability to visualize cleft lips and normal
lips was compared between the two techniques.
RESULTS. Of the 71 fetuses studied, faces were seen in 68 and not seen in three by
either 2D or 3D sonography. Abnormal lips were seen in five fetuses on both 2D and 3D
sonograms. Of the remaining fetuses, 3D sonography was able to confirm the presence
of a normal lip in 92% (58/63) compared with 76% (48/63) with 2D sonography. In the
subgroup of fetuses less than 24 weeks’ estimated gestational age, 3D sonography
confirmed a normal lip in 93% (38/41) of fetuses as compared with 68% (28/41) for 2D
sonography. There was no difference between 3D and 2D in the subgroup of fetuses
older than 24 weeks. One false-positive finding of cleft lip was observed at 36 weeks’
gestational age with the rendered surface display on 3D sonography, whereas the 3D
planar views of the same volume showed the lips to be normal.
CONCLUSION. 3D sonography was able to confirm the presence of normal lips
more frequently than did 2D sonography in fetuses less than 24 weeks’ gestational
age. Abnormal lips were seen on both 2D and 3D sonograms; however, 3D Images of
cleft lip were easier to understand for both the family and clinical colleagues.
AJR 1995;165:1233-i237
Received April 12, 1 995: accepted after revision
June22, 1995.
1 Department of Radiology-0610, University of
Califomia, San Diego, 9500 Gilman Dr., La Jolla, CA
92093. Address correspondence to D. H. Pretorius.
2Department of Family and Preventive Medi-
cine-0361 -C, University of California, San Diego,
La Jolla, CA 92093.
Use of three-dimensional (3D) sonognaphy of the fetus has been reported in 5ev-
enal recent investigations [1-9]. A particularly promising application of 3D sonogra-
phy is the diagnosis of fetal anomalies [3, 5, 7]. Cleft lip and palate is an example of
an anomaly that is difficult to detect by conventional two-dimensional (2D) sonogna-
phy [1 0-12]. As a cleft lip and palate is associated with other anomalies and chro-
mosome abnormalities in 10-15% of fetuses [13-15], early diagnosis may aid in the
management of the pregnancy [1 6]. In this article we compare 2D and 3D sono-
graphic images of the fetal face to determine whether 3D sonognaphy can improve
prenatal evaluation of fetal lips in comparison with conventional 2D sonography.
Materials and Methods
Study Population
A total of 71 fetuses (15-39 weeks’ gestational age) were examined with 3D sonography
between March and November 1 994. Sixty high-risk pregnant women undergoing conven-
tional 2D sonography at a peninatal referral center were recruited, and one patient requested
to participate because of a family history of cleft lip. Indications for 2D sonography scanning
included advanced maternal age (n = 8), family history of cleft lip (n = 8), teratogen expo-
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 52.73.204.196 on 05/16/22 from IP address 52.73.204.196. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved