591
CONTINUOUS MICROINDENTATION AND MICROSCRATCH MEASUREMENTS OF
METAL-CERAMIC ADHESIVE STRENGTHS
S. VENKATARAMAN°, D.L. KOHLSTEDT° AND W.W. GERBERICH°
" Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, University of Minnesota,
Minneapolis, MN 55455.
** Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455.
ABSTRACT
To investigate the effect of heat-treatment on the adhesion of Pt thin films to NiO
substrates, the strain energy release rate, interfacial fracture toughness and interfacial shear
strength were determined from continuous microscratch and continuous microindentation
experiments. Samples were prepared by sputtering Pt onto single crystals of NiO, followed by
a heat-treatment at temperatures of 300, 500 and 800'C and an oxygen partial pressure of either
0.21 or 105 atm. Continuous microscratch tests were performed by driving a conical indenter
with either a 1 or 5 jim tip radius simultaneously into and across the Pt film. From the
magnitude of the critical load at the point of film delamination and the area of the delaminated
piece of the thin film, the strain energy release rate (practical work of adhesion) and interfacial
fracture toughness were calculated. The practical work of adhesion and interfacial fracture
toughness increased from 0.2 J/m
2
and 0.2 MPa
4
m, respectively, for as-sputtered samples to 4.6
J/m2 and 1 MPa'Im for samples heat-treated at 500
0
C and 10"- atm. Preliminary analysis of
continuous microindentation results for Pt/NiO samples yielded interfacial shear strengths of 270
MPa for as-sputtered samples and 725 MPa for samples heat-treated at 500'C and 10-5 atm.
While these values are in good agreement with those determined by other methods for metal-
ceramic systems, there are sufficient differences in test method for a single system to require
additional analysis of the proposed models.
INTRODUCTION
As the number of applications for high-temperature materials increases, a fundamental
understanding of the bonding at metal-ceramic interfaces is required to predict their mechanical
and adhesive strengths, so that their properties and processing can be optimized. Although many
techniques for evaluating mechanical and adhesive properties of interfaces are available, the
microindentation and microscratch techniques have assumed special importance in the last few
years [1-2]. These techniques are simple, and samples can be tested in the same configuration
as they are used in service conditions. Moreover, these techniques enable the determination of
various properties such as hardness, elastic moduli and adhesion strength.
This paper addresses the adhesion of metal-ceramic systems, with special reference to
heat-treated thin films of Pt on NiO. For this system it is known that heat-treatments at reduced
oxygen partial pressures result in diffusion of Ni into the Pt, thus producing an intermetallic
zone at the interface [3]. Hence the adhesion strength can be increased enormously and
systematically by controlling the time, temperature, and oxygen partial pressure of the anneal.
The importance and the difficulty in quantifying the adhesion strengths of such reacted systems
is obvious, and very few techniques are available for this purpose. Continuous nicroindentation
and microscratch testing provide two types of solution.
A high-resolution microindenter [1,4] with capabilities of continuous microindentation
and microscratch testing was used. In the continuous microindentation experiments, a Vickers
diamond indenter was driven into the sample at controlled rates, until a preselected load (or
depth) was reached. The indenter was then withdrawn from the sample. The load and depth
Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. Vol. 239. ©1992 Materials Research Society