Journal of Electronic Testing
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10836-018-5724-y
Dynamic Analog/RF Alternate Test Strategies Based on On-chip
Learning
Parth Kansara
1
· Sharanabasavaraja Bheema Reddy
1
· Louay Abdallah
2
· Ke Huang
1
Received: 15 November 2017 / Accepted: 28 March 2018
© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2018
Abstract
Analog/RF alternate test schemes have been extensively studied in the past decade with the goal of replacing time-consuming
and expensive specification tests with low-cost alternate measurements. A common approach in analog/RF alternate test
is to build non-linear regression models to map the specification tests to alternate measurements, or to learn a pass/fail
separation boundary directly in the space of alternate measurements. Among various challenges that have been discussed
in alternate test, the model stationarity is a major bottle-neck that prevents test engineers from deploying it in long-term
applications. In this work, we show that alternate test strategies can be implemented on-chip using analog/RF Built-In Self-
Test (BIST) circuitry. Moreover, model refinement and dynamic adaptation can be achieved based on an automatic on-chip
learning structure. Effectiveness of the proposed approach is demonstrated using experimental results from an RF Low Noise
Amplifier (LNA) and its BIST implementation.
Keywords Analog/RF testing · Alternate test · On-chip learning
1 Introduction
The test cost reduction of analog/RF integrated circuits
(ICs) has been extensively studies in recent years. The
high cost of analog/RF ICs is mainly caused by the
need of using expensive automated test equipment (ATE)
to perform parametric measurements at high frequencies,
the lengthy measurement setup and test times, and the
inevitable manual process for setting up various types of
measurements. Various approaches have been proposed
to address the high cost of testing analog/RF circuits,
including alternate test [3, 24, 26], machine learning-based
approach [20], subset specification test selection [4, 5, 14,
18, 22], [13], wafer-level spatial correlation modeling [10,
12, 15, 16, 27], etc. Among existing test cost reduction
Responsible Editor: M. Barragan
Ke Huang
khuang@mail.sdsu.edu
1
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering,
San Diego State University, 5500 Campanile Drive,
San Diego, CA, 92182-1309, USA
2
Dolphin Integration, 39 avenue du Granier, BP 65 - Inovallee,
F38242 Meylan Cedex, France
practices, alternate test has been widely studies due to its
ability to accurately predict specification tests from a set
of low-cost alternate measurements [24, 26]. The goal is
to build non-linear correlation models that map the high-
cost specification tests to a set of sophisticatedly selected
low-cost alternate measurements. Once the models are
established, for new Devices Under Test (DUTs), only low-
cost alternate measurements are taken and used to predict
specification tests or provide device pass/fail decision
directly in the space of alternate measurements.
Alternate test approach was originally proposed to pre-
dict specification tests in an offline manner, i.e., external
computational resources are used to build and store the cor-
relation/prediction models and predict circuit performances
or pass/fail decisions where these computational resources
are available. In [9], baseband DSP processor was used to
calibrate RF circuits based on a set of alternate measure-
ments. In [25], a more compact and customized on-chip
learning model was used to tune the performances of an RF
LNA. A custom-designed analog neural network with mul-
tilayer perceptron (MLP) structure was designed to tune the
LNA to enhance its performances. However, the learning
of the MLP in [25] was still performed based on external
computational resources by communicating model param-
eter updates with a host computer. While offline model