Integrated Synthesis of Biodiesel, Bioethanol, Isobutene, and
Glycerol Ethers from Algae
Veró nica de la Cruz,
†
Sara Herna ́ ndez,
†
Mariano Martín,*
,†
and Ignacio E. Grossmann
‡
†
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Salamanca, Pza. Caídos 1-5, 37008 Salamanca, Spain
‡
Department of Chemical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon University. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213, United States
ABSTRACT: In this paper, we design an integrated process for the production of diesel substitutes, biodiesel and glycerol
ethers, from algae with internal production of the intermediates ethanol and isobutene. The starch from the algae is converted
into glucose. Part of it is fermented to ethanol so that we produce the alcohol needed to transesterify the algae oil while the rest is
fermented to isobutene, which is needed in the production of glycerol ethers to enhance biofuels production capacity. We use
CHEMCAD coupled with MATLAB for the rigorous simulation of the integrated biorefinery and evaluate the algae composition
for such integrated facility. This is followed by energy integration using SYNHEAT and a detailed economic analysis. The
integrated facility has promising production cost for liquid fuels, 0.46 $/gal, and an investment costs of $205M, almost half the
production cost and only and investment $40M above the plant that buys the isobutene from the market.
1. INTRODUCTION
For quite some time biodiesel facilities have been designed for
the production of this particular biofuel from cooking oil, algae,
or vegetable oil. Even though they are regarded as biorefineries,
they actually are focused on the production of one main product,
biodiesel, and some byproducts (i.e., fertilizers, glycerol) while
some raw materials came from fossil resources, for instance,
methanol. Even though the use of methanol was traditionally
supported by its lower price and faster reaction times, Severson et
al.
1
proved that it is economically competitive to produce
biodiesel using ethanol. Furthermore, Martı ́ n and Grossmann
2
integrated the production of bioethanol and biodiesel from algae
oil resulting in competitive production costs compared to those
resulting from the use of methanol. With the current need for
sustainable liquid fuels, a number of alternatives have been
presented to increase the production of biofuels using the
byproducts of the current biorefineries. For instance, the
production of biodiesel generates glycerol. The high price as a
result of its use in the cosmetic and food industries has been an
asset for the production of biodiesel and it has improved the
economics of such plants. However, the increase in the
production of biodiesel is saturating the market, and new uses
for glycerol are being developed to help reduce our dependence
on fossil fuels. Recently, Cheng et al.
3
developed a process for the
use of glycerol to produce oxygenated derivates, glycerol ethers.
The advantage is that they can also be used as diesel substitutes
increasing the yield to biofuels.
4
The drawback is that, apart from
glycerol, the second raw material is isobutene, an expensive C4
chemical typically obtained in the fractionation of crude.
However, van Leeuwen
5
proved that it is possible to produce
isobutene from sugars and recently Martı ́ n and Grossmann
6
found that its production from biomass containing glucose and
xylose is economically promising.
Algae are a particularly rich raw material whose composition
consists mainly of lipids, starch, and protein. Therefore, from
algae we have all the components to design an integrated facility
that produces ethanol and isobutene from starch as inter-
mediates, oil from the lipids that is transesterified with ethanol
producing biodiesel (Fatty acid ethyl ester, FAEE), while the
glycerol, byproduct of the transesterification reaction, reacts with
isobutene producing glycerol ethers which are diesel substitutes.
Since isobutene and bioethanol are produced from the starchy
biomass within the algae, the composition of the algae may need
to be adjusted so that we can self-sufficiently produce the
intermediates that are needed for the production of biodiesel and
glycerol ethers avoiding the need for fossil based raw materials.
Thus, in this paper, we present the conceptual design of an
integrated biorefinery from algae, which produces diesel
substitutes, biodiesel (FAEE), and glycerol ethers, but which
can also produce isobutene and ethanol, for internal use. We use
a hybrid approach employing modular process simulators such as
CHEMCAD coupled with equation based software, MATLAB.
After the rigorous simulation, we design a heat exchanger
network and perform an economic evaluation of the operation of
such facility.
The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the
description of the different sections of the process and the main
operating conditions and constraints. Section 3 describes the
modeling approach using CHEMCAD and MATLAB. Section 4
presents results from the material and energy balances, water
consumption, and the economic evaluation. Finally, in section 5,
we draw some conclusions.
2. OVERALL PROCESS DESCRIPTION
As seen in Figure 1, we divide the process in five sections: algae
oil production, ethanol production from starch, isobutene
production from starch, biodiesel production from oil, and
finally high glycerol ethers (di- and tri-tert-butyl glycerol: DTBG
+ TTBG = hTBG) production from glycerol.
Received: June 5, 2014
Revised: August 13, 2014
Accepted: August 13, 2014
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© XXXX American Chemical Society A dx.doi.org/10.1021/ie5022738 | Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX