Dibenzo[a,c]phenazine: A Polarity-Insensitive Hydrogen-Bonding Probe
Debarati Dey,
†
Adity Bose,
†
Dhananjay Bhattacharyya,
‡
Samita Basu,*
,†
Shyam Sundar Maity,
§
and Sanjib Ghosh
§
Chemical Sciences DiVision, and Biophysics DiVision, Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics,
1/AF, Bidhannagar, Kolkata 700 064, India, and Department of Chemistry,
Presidency College, 86/1, College Street, Kolkata 700 073, India
ReceiVed: April 25, 2007; In Final Form: August 14, 2007
A derivative of phenazine, dibenzo[a,c]phenazine (DBPZ), can be used as a very good hydrogen-bonding
probe unlike its parent phenazine molecule. Steady-state absorption and fluorescence studies reveal that DBPZ
is completely insensitive to polarity of the medium. However, DBPZ can form a hydrogen bond very efficiently
in its first excited singlet state. The extent of this excited-state hydrogen-bond formation depends both on
size and on hydrogen-bond donor ability of the solvents. Time-resolved fluorescence studies and theoretical
calculations also suggest that this hydrogen-bond formation is much more favorable in the excited state as
compared to the ground state. In the excited state, the electron density is pushed toward the nitrogen atoms
from the benzene rings, thereby increasing the dipole moment of the DBPZ molecule. Although the dipole
moment of DBPZ increases upon photoexcitation, like other polarity probes, the molecule remains fully
insensitive to the polarity of the interacting solvent. This unusual behavior of DBPZ as compared to simple
phenazine and other polarity probes is due to the structure of the molecule. Hydrogen atoms at the 1 and 8
positions of DBPZ are sterically interacting with a lone pair of electrons on the proximate nitrogen atoms and
make both of the nitrogen atoms inaccessible to solvent molecules. For this reason, DBPZ cannot sense the
polarity of the medium. However, DBPZ can only sense solvents, those that have hydrogen with some
electropositive nature, that is, the hydrogen-bond donating solvents. Hydrogen being the smallest among all
elements can only interact with the lone pair of electrons of nitrogen atoms. Thus, DBPZ can act as a sensor
for the hydrogen-bond donating solvents irrespective of their dielectrics.
Introduction
Hydrogen bonding is one of the fundamental elements of
chemical structure and reactivity of water, proteins, and DNA
building blocks of life.
1-3
Intermolecular hydrogen bonding is
a site-specific local interaction between hydrogen donor and
acceptor molecules that plays a dominant role in various forms
of molecular recognition processes. The nature of the hydrogen
bond in solution is of particular interest, and it has been probed
by diverse experimental and theoretical methods. It is evident
from the literature that there are quite a large number of
phenazine derivatives,
4,5
which show significant differences in
their dipole moment in the ground and excited states on
photoexcitation. In such cases, the solvent molecules undergo
reorganization around the solute molecules according to their
own dipole moment and hydrogen-bonding capacity to minimize
the total energy of the solute-solvent system. For this dipole-
dipole interaction, the emission spectra of those molecules
depend very much on the polarity of the solvent employed. Such
polarity probes show considerable red shift of the fluorescence
maxima in the polar solvents as compared to nonpolar medium.
This phenomenon is popularly known as solvation.
6-8
However,
it is a very rare observation in the literature that a molecule
with a dipole moment higher in the excited state as compared
to the ground state remains insensitive to polarity (or dielectric)
but sensitive to the hydrogen-bonding capacity of the solvent.
In this Article, we would like to report on such a molecule,
that is, dibenzo[a,c]phenazine (DBPZ), and its activity as an
efficient hydrogen-bonding probe unlike its parent phenazine
molecule. Because of the planar structure and rigid framework
of the fused ring system, the conformational and configurational
relaxation processes are not feasible enough in DBPZ. Only
the solvent relaxation process becomes important in its first
excited singlet state. Photoexcitation of DBPZ results in
significant changes in the spatial charge distribution around its
nitrogen atoms like other polarity probes. Yet surprisingly DBPZ
remains insensitive to the polarity of the solvents. The structure
of the molecule might be responsible for its peculiar behavior.
Steady-state absorption and fluorescence studies reveal that
DBPZ forms hydrogen bonding with hydroxylic solvents in the
excited state. The extent of hydrogen-bond formation depends
on the hydrogen-bond donor ability (R) and steric bulk of the
solvent. Time-resolved fluorescence studies suggest that the
hydrogen-bond formation is much more facilitated in the excited
* Corresponding author. Telephone: +91-33-2337-5345. Fax: +91-33-
2337-4637. E-mail: samita.basu@saha.ac.in.
†
Chemical Sciences Division, Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics.
‡
Biophysics Division, Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics.
§
Presidency College.
CHART 1
10500 J. Phys. Chem. A 2007, 111, 10500-10506
10.1021/jp0731811 CCC: $37.00 © 2007 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 09/25/2007