Computational Investigation of Electronic and Steric Effects in
Surface Reactions of Metalorganic Precursors on Functionalized
Silicon Surfaces
Yichen Duan, Jia-Ming Lin, and Andrew V. Teplyakov*
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware 19716, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Steric and electronic effects play a profound
role in determining the mechanisms of surface reactions. In the
case of reactions of metalorganic precursors on solid
prefunctionalized surfaces, the contribution of these effects
has to be considered both for the incoming metalorganic
precursor molecule and for the functionalized surface itself.
This study uses density functional theory calculations with
simple cluster models to investigate the technologically
important reactions of tetrakis(dimethylamido)titanium
(TDMAT) and trimethylaluminum (TMA) with silicon surfaces functionalized with preadsorbed amines. This approach
provides an opportunity to compare the contribution of electronic effects in the process of transamination for TDMAT and in
the process of aluminum deposition followed by methane desorption for TMA. Bulky dimethylamido substituents of TDMAT
are shown to suppress the electronic effects of the surface-bound amines unless the very open surface-bound structures of -NH
2
and -NHF are compared. At the same time, the relatively open structure of TMA allows for a comparison unobscured by the
ligands of a precursor. A comparison within a number of substituted amines bound to the silicon surface is performed and
electronic differences are explained by following the properties of the surface hydrogen needed for eliminating a substituent
ligand during the deposition step.
1. INTRODUCTION
Steric and electronic effects have long been used as the guiding
principles for explaining the stability and geometry of
molecules
1
or for manipulating the thermodynamics or kinetics
of chemical reactions.
2-4
This combination has been studied in
detail and reviewed for a wide variety of classical synthetic
reactions,
5
catalytic processes,
6,7
biomedical applications,
8,9
and
nanoelectronics.
10,11
While major efforts have been dedicated
to optimizing the combination of steric and electronic factors
for selected reactions,
5,6,8-10
substantial attention has also been
directed at dif ferentiating the role of these effects in a number of
processes.
7,12,13
More recently, substantial interest of science and engineering
communities turned to the role of steric and electronic effects
in surface processes ,
14,15
since treating a surface as a
(macro-)molecular reagent has been successful in a number
of applications, including organic modification of semi-
conductors
16-18
and heterogeneous catalysis.
19-21
However,
in this case treating these two types of factors as independent is
complicated by the role of the surface.
Surface effects may be involved in both steric and electronic
aspects of surface reactions. Not only does the surface restrict
the geometry of a process but also it affects the electronics of
chemical transformations. In addition, the presence of
neighboring surface species, seemingly not directly involved
in the reaction, may influence both steric and electronic factors.
In other words, differentiation of steric and electronic effects
can be challenging in homogeneous processes;
22,23
on surfaces
this task can be even more complex.
24,25
A practical approach to evaluate steric and electronic factors
is often related to a concept of acidity versus basicity of
functional groups on solid surfaces.
26-28
One of the recent
studies applied this concept to evaluate reactivity of amino-
functionalized surfaces toward adsorption and following surface
transamination reactions of metalorganic compounds with
amino-based ligands,
29
utilizing the electron-withdrawing or
electron-donating nature of the substituents. In the present
work, technologically important reactions of tetrakis-
(dimethylamido)titanium (TDMAT) and trimethylalane
(TMA) with the cornerstone of microelectronics, function-
alized silicon surfaces, are used as probes to estimate the initial
ability of the lone pair on a nitrogen atom of surface amino
functionality to nucleophilically attack the electrophilic site of
the incoming metalorganic precursor molecule, and further
surface processes following this initial attachment are evaluated.
TMA is a common precursor used for deposition of Al
2
O
3
films
onto the surface.
26
Al
2
O
3
film can serve as a protective layer
that prevents the surface from further oxidation or can be
utilized as an electrical insulator on silicon.
30
TDMAT is often
used as a precursor to deposit titanium-containing thin films,
Received: March 20, 2015
Revised: May 11, 2015
Published: May 22, 2015
Article
pubs.acs.org/JPCC
© 2015 American Chemical Society 13670 DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpcc.5b02722
J. Phys. Chem. C 2015, 119, 13670-13681