CFD ANALYSIS OF NO
x
FORMATION IN WASTE-TO-ENERGY SYSTEMS USING DETAILED CHEMICAL
KINETIC MODELING
Alex Frank
Columbia University
New York, NY 10027
Marco J. Castaldi
Columbia University
New York, NY 10027
ABSTRACT
This study was undertaken to better understand the
governing processes and reaction conditions under which NO
x
is produced in Waste to Energy (WtE) boilers. A three
dimensional CFD model was created and calculated using the
GRI 3.0, 50 species, 309 step detailed chemical kinetic model
(DCKM) for methane/ethane combustion. Model results for
primary NO
x
emissions and other pollutants agree well with
collected data, proving the fidelity of the model. NO was the
primary pollutant accounting for approximately 99% of the
total NO
x
emissions. Fuel bound nitrogen was found to be the
main source of NO produced in the boiler with thermal and
prompt mechanisms having lesser impacts. Three principal
intermediates were identified in the formation of NO; NH,
HNO, and NCO. The assumption of fuel nitrogen conversion
to either NH
3
or HCN is an unknown parameter that was
shown to have a small impact on NO emissions, indicating
that this is an area that should not be explored further in this
continuing study. Furthermore, varying the boiler pressure had
a small impact on final NO emissions, indicating that this is
not a condition that should be considered for plant operation.
The next phase of this research will include the development
of a reduced DCKM in order to expedite the running of new
scenarios for future studies as well as optimization of boiler
geometry and combustion mixing to achieve the lowest
possible NO
x
emissions.
INTRODUCTION
Waste incineration is a technology commonly
employed throughout the world due to its ability to reduce the
mass and volume of waste by 70% and 90%, respectively,
while also generating electricity. While it remains an effective
way to reduce waste diverted to landfills, environmental
concerns such as stack emissions are of great importance and
under constant scrutiny. As a result, Waste-to-Energy (WtE)
facility emissions have been on a steady decline for many
years. This reduction has occurred due to both optimization of
combustion within the boiler and the introduction of various
control technologies.
Of the various pollutants emitted, NO
x
emissions
still pose a significant challenge. Currently, NO
x
is controlled
mostly by Selective NonCatalytic Reduction (SNCR) and is
able to meet the federal emission limit of 205 ppmdv and 150
ppmdv (7% O
2
) for existing and new WTE facilities
respectively [1]. Furthermore, there have been various control
technologies developed such as the LN™ and VLN™ systems
designed by Covanta Energy partnered with Martin GmbH.
The VLN™ system draws cool gas from the rear of the waste
bed and re-injects it in the upper section of the furnace while
also optimizing the ratio between secondary and primary air in
order to reduce the formation of NO
x
and improve combustion
efficiency [2].
While these control technologies are proven to be
very effective in plant operations around the world, the details
governing the formation and destruction of NO
x
are not fully
understood.
Over the past several years, several CFD models
have been built to better understand and optimize the design of
WtE systems. Some models were simplified to include only a
gaseous, over-bed boundary condition that ignores the solid
waste burning on the bed [3]. More complex models simulate
the solid waste combustion, burnout, mass reduction, and
include fly ash among other phenomena in addition to the
gaseous combustion products [4]. In the past, both of these
model types generally assumed global reactions that
encompassed the entire boiler, mostly ignoring kinetics and
instead focusing solely on fluid dynamics. Therefore, they
were good at predicting most pollutants, but generally lack the
ability to model very intricate and complex kinetics present in
the formation of NO
x
.
Most often, when NO
x
is of interest, simulations are
run which greatly simplify inlet boundary conditions and
Proceedings of the 20th Annual North American Waste-to-Energy Conference
NAWTEC20
April 23-25, 2012, Portland, Maine, USA
NAWTEC20-70
1 Copyright © 2012 by ASME