The Lesser Number: On Action and
Geoengineering
Agustín Mercado-Reyes
Abstract: The current crises put before us alternatives of action that require
decision; for example, the decision of whether to deploy or investigate SRM
geoengineering to counter global warming, which is here taken as the cen-
tral example. Attending to the ontological richness of value in the elements
of the world, of which scientifc models and thought are a very particular
and limited kind, can cast a diferent light into the decision process, which
otherwise would almost unavoidably devolve into “infernal alternatives,” as
Isabelle Stengers calls them: impossible choices between two evils.
1.
A
fer her father died in 1980, Mary Catherine Bateson put together his last
book out of his loose hand-drawn diagrams, unpublished manuscripts,
conference notes and her own words. In that book, the shade of Gregory
Bateson strives to explain the existence of holes and gaps in the pattern of our
very existence (Bateson and Bateson 2005, 59). Tere are gaps between our
perception and the real thing: gaps between measurement and the precise state
of the object, between the model and the object modeled, and so on. Tese gaps
are bridged by mind, which to Bateson is a component of being that permeates
everything in the guise of structure or information.
Bateson thus tries to think about the myths and superstitions of the
modern age, which are not populated by angels and demons but by “deep un-
conscious philosophies,” our default ways of bridging the gaps. Some of these
superstitions lead us to profoundly material positions, centered in quantity;
© Environmental Philosophy
All rights reserved. ISSN: 1718-0918
doi:
Online First:
Agustín Mercado-Reyes, Centro de Investigaciones Interdisciplinarias en Ciencias y Humanidades,
UNAM E-mail: agustin_mr@ciencias.unam.mx