Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Energy Conversion and Management
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/enconman
Thermo-economic evaluation of a hybrid solar-conventional energy supply
in a zero liquid discharge wastewater treatment plant
Ahmadreza Najafi, Ali Jafarian
⁎
, Jamal Darand
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Thermo-economic
Hybrid solar-conventional energy supply
Wastewater treatment
Brine concentrator
Crystallizer
Zero liquid discharge plant
ABSTRACT
In this paper, thermo-economic evaluation of hybrid solar-conventional energy supply in a zero liquid discharge
plant has been conducted. The zero liquid discharge plant includes a brine concentrator and a crystallizer. Brine
concentrator and crystallizer utilize falling film and forced circulation evaporators respectively. The plant was
studied thermo-economically in capital of Iran, Tehran city weather conditions. The plant performance and
economics were investigated in four design (winter, spring, summer and autumn design) conditions based on the
seasonal weather data and compared with the conventional energy supply system. It was concluded that the
design proposed based on average weather conditions shows no economic advantage over the conventional
design; due to accounting for financial aids and subsides for the fuel cost at 0.05 $/m
3
,affecting the steam and
water costs. However, a parametric study demonstrated that if the financial aids associated with the fuel are
disregarded, it will have a pronounced effect on the cost of steam and produced water.
1. Introduction
Today, the need for recycling industrial wastewater is one of the
most important problems in society; and due to the faster growing
population, and subsequently, the growing industries, it is deemed even
more necessary [1]. In addition to environmental problems and water
shortage, energy is considered another important reason in industrial
wastewater management [2]. Therefore, thermodynamic study and
economic analysis of water and power cogeneration plants in the scope
of industrial wastewater can demonstrate the feasibility of different
methods to resolve the aforementioned issues [3]. One of the solutions
to water scarcity is recycling and concentration of the industrial was-
tewater. Desalination is the process to remove the dissolved salts to
produce fresh water. Multi-effect distillation (MED) and multistage
flash distillation (MSF) are among the most important processes to
produce fresh water. Although desalination processes have succeeded
in slightly improving the water scarcity problem, they require ex-
pensive investments due to their high energy consumption [4]. Because
of the rising fuel costs, environmental contaminant and greenhouse gas
emission, using fossil fuels to setup the aforementioned processes are
not efficient options [5]. Regarding the problems with fossil fuels, re-
newable energy resources seem like an appropriate alternative [6].
Among renewable energy resources, using solar energy has a lot of
advantages, especially in areas with high sunlight, such as the Middle
East [7]. Accordingly, a lot of researches have been carried out on using
solar energy for desalination.
Shaobo et al. [8] provided an improved MSF design based on
“Pinch” technology. Sharaf et al. [9] studied two configuration of multi
effect distillation-vapor compression in both economic and thermo-
dynamic aspects. Their studies showed that for a 4545 m
3
/day design,
water would be priced at 2.1 and 1.5 $/m
3
for multi effect distillation-
thermal vapor compression (MED-TVC), and multi effect distillation-
mechanical vapor compression (MED-MVC), respectively. Palenzuela
et al. [10] studies different configuration of parabolic trough solar
power plants with distillers designs in arid environments. In one of the
designs, they used a low-temperature distiller in the place of the con-
denser in a solar power plant, and studied the optimization of this de-
sign by evaluating the turbine discharge. Bataineh [11] studied the
yearly operation of a MED-MVC in Jordan. He demonstrated that
highest efficiency of the system is achieved by placing the collectors
towards south, and solar fraction change has negligible variation in
saturated vapor production. Delgado et al. [12] demonstrated in their
thermoeconomic study of a solar powered reverse osmosis and MED-
TVC seawater desalination plant, that highest system efficiency is
achieved when the reverse osmosis unit is connected to the local power
grid. Kouta et al. [13] provided an entropy, exergy, and cost analyses of
a solar driven cogeneration systems using supercritical CO
2
Brayton
cycles and multiple effect evaporation with a thermal vapor
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2019.03.059
Received 20 December 2018; Received in revised form 18 March 2019; Accepted 19 March 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: jafarian@modares.ac.ir (A. Jafarian).
Energy Conversion and Management 188 (2019) 276–295
0196-8904/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T