LETTER TO THE EDITOR
TCR αβ and CD19-depleted haploidentical stem cell transplant
with reduced intensity conditioning for
Hoyeraal–Hreidarsson syndrome with RTEL1 mutation
Bone Marrow Transplantation (2016) 51, 753–754; doi:10.1038/
bmt.2015.352; published online 25 January 2016
The eponym Hoyeraal–Hreidarsson (HH) syndrome was first
coined by Aalfs et al. describing similar cases previously reported
by Hoyeraal in 1970 and then Hreidarsson in 1988.
1
HH syndrome
is a multisystem telomere biology disorder that represents the
most severe clinical variant of dyskeratosis congenita (DC).
2
A clinical diagnosis can be made if patients have at least four of
the following six features associated with this disorder that
includes bone marrow failure, intrauterine growth retardation,
microcephaly, developmental delay, cerebellar hypoplasia and
immunodeficiency.
3
There is significant genetic overlap between
HH syndrome and DC, and the genetic defect can be identified in
~ 60% of patients with HH syndrome. Mutations in genes required
for both telomere maintenance and genomic stability such as
RTEL1 (regulator of telomere elongation helicase 1) and DKC1
(dyskerin) are classically associated with HH syndrome. Early-onset
severe bone marrow failure and immunodeficiency (classically
T
+
B
-
NK
-
) may necessitate urgent stem cell transplantation that
can be curative for both marrow failure and immunodeficiency
but is unlikely to have any beneficial impact on the other aspects
of this disease.
4
Initial attempts at stem cell transplantation
using conventional myeloablative conditioning in DC were
disappointing due to the severe systemic toxicity of conditioning
chemotherapy. Reduced intensity conditioning (RIC) has been
a fairly successful strategy with reasonable outcomes.
5–8
Combination of RIC with T-cell depletion from grafts raises the
concerns of non-engraftment but successful CD34
+
cell selected
haploidentical transplant has been recently reported.
9
Novel
ex vivo T-cell depletion techniques using TCR αβ and CD19
depletion have many potential advantages. Removal of αβ-T cells
by 4–5 logs can reduce the risk of GvHD but at the same time
facilitates excellent CD34
+
cell recovery while retaining γδ T cells,
dendritic cells, natural killer (NK) cells and monocyte/myeloid
cells, thereby ensuring early robust engraftment and immune
reconstitution. This technique has demonstrated excellent early
results in paediatric nonmalignant stem cell transplantation.
10,11
The strategy of combining RIC with T-cell depletion technique
using TCR-αβ and CD19 depletion appears attractive in DC
patients for whom stem cell transplantation has been challenging.
We describe an infant who was born at 34-week gestation with
a birth weight of 800 g and a platelet count of 80 × 10
9
/L. The
severe growth retardation was initially thought to be due to
placental insufficiency. The thrombocytopenia resolved tempora-
rily but progressed to severe bone marrow failure by the age of
4 months. Bone marrow aspiration showed a hypocellular marrow
with no clonal cytogenetic changes. Quantitative serum Ig
estimation was normal but lymphocyte subset analysis showed
low NK cell numbers with normal T and B cells. Combination of
these features with microcephaly, developmental delay, severe
cerebellar hypoplasia on magnetic resonance imaging scan and
short telomere length confirmed a clinical diagnosis of HH
syndrome. Mutation analyses for known genes (NHP2, NOP10,
TERT, TINF2 and WRAP53) associated with DC was negative. Trio
whole-exome sequencing (WES) for proband and biological
parents was performed through an institutional review board
approved research project. DNA was extracted from peripheral
leukocytes, and WES was performed on Illumina’s HiSeq 2000
(San Diego, CA, USA) as per the manufacturer’s protocol. The reads
were mapped to hg19, and variants were identified using Broad
Institute’s GATK and annotated with ANNOVAR. The results were
then filtered to include only protein altering variants that were
absent or rare (allele frequency o0.01) from dbSNP, 1000
genomes, exome variant server and in-house exome database
of Asian individuals, and were consistent with the phenotype
and mode of inheritance. WES revealed biallelic mutations
in RTEL1 (chr20:62319369G4A; c.1561G4A; p.Asp521Asn and
chr20:62319116A4G; c.1474A4G; p.Met492Val). Both these
variants were absent from control populations, altered highly
conserved amino-acid residue and were predicted to be
pathogenic by in silico software (Polyphen-2 (http://genetics.
bwh.harvard.edu/pph2/) and SIFT (http://sift.bii.a-star.edu.sg/)).
Neither variant has been reported previously. The variant
Met492Val was inherited from his mother, whereas the variant
Asp521Asn was de novo. The variants were validated by Sanger
sequencing.
We proceeded with haploidentical transplantation due to
severe pancytopenia needing frequent blood product infusions,
and the lack of a suitable donor. The transplant was performed at
10 months of age using his father as the stem cell donor.
The father was killer Ig-like receptor (KIR) mismatched and
of B haplotype on KIR genotyping. RIC chemotherapy with ATG
(Thymoglobulin, 2.5 mg/kg per day × 4 days), fludarabine (40 mg/m
2
per day × 4 days) and treosulfan (12 g/m
2
per day × 3 days) was
used. GCSF-mobilized peripheral blood stem cells were collected
and processed by negative selection for TCR-αβ and CD19. Graft
engineering was achieved using the Miltenyi Biotec CliniMACS
system (CliniMACS; Miltenyi Biotec, Bergisch Gladbach, Germany).
Infused product had CD34+ cells of 36 × 10
6
/kg and TCR-αβ cells
4.5 × 10
4
/kg. No GvHD prophylaxis was used. Rapid platelet
engraftment on D+11 and neutrophil engraftment on D+15 were
noted. He developed mild mucositis and feeding difficulty
needing prolonged nasogastric tube feeding. Apart from one
episode of culture negative fever, no major complications were
observed in immediate post-transplant period. There were no
episodes of peri-transplant viral or fungal infections. He is
currently 10 months post transplant with no major infections or
GvHD. Day 30, 120 and 245 lymphocyte subset analysis continues
to demonstrate excellent immune reconstitution (Figures 1 and 2).
Chimerism analyses were performed initially on day 30 from bone
marrow and subsequently from peripheral blood. These showed
100% donor chimerism and we did not observe any mixed
chimerism.
Isolated mild thrombocytopenia in a neonate followed by
temporary normalization of platelet count has been described in
children with congenital amegakaryocytic thrombocytopenia but
is not a well-described feature of DC. Different mutations have
been identified in both HH syndrome and DC; however, RTEL1
Bone Marrow Transplantation (2016) 51, 753 – 754
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited All rights reserved 0268-3369/16
www.nature.com/bmt