TBM
TBM page 87 of 95
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Implications
Practice: This study provides practical know-
ledge on the adaptation of graphic training
methods to youth in impoverished environments.
Policy: The results provide new data to aid in the
development of policies directed at increasing
the reach of current HIV-testing systems.
Research: This study expands implementa-
tion theory to include self-implemented health
practices.
1
Hallie E. Ford Center, College of
Public Health and Human Sciences,
Oregon State University, Corvallis,
OR 97331, USA
2
Oregon Health Sciences University,
Portland, OR 97239, USA
3
FASDO, Yatima Group Fund,
Tanzania
4
University of South Carolina,
Columbia, SC 29208, USA
Abstract
Tanzanian youth have high levels of HIV risk and poor access
to HIV-testing. Oral self-implemented testing (Oral-SIT)
provides an alternative that reduces barriers to HIV-testing.
We examined adaptations to Oral-SIT training components
in a randomized experiment to evaluate a “train-the-trainer”
strategy for improving comprehension of graphic training
materials. Participants (N = 257, age = 14−19 years) were
randomly assigned to one of two self-training conditions:
graphic instruction book (GIB) or Video-GIB. Outcomes included
behavioral performance fdelity, self-reported comprehension,
and intentions to seek treatment. Video-GIB participants,
relative to GIB-only participants, had higher performance
fdelity scores, made fewer performance errors, had better
instruction comprehension, and were more likely to intend to
seek treatment. Oral-SIT timing errors were signifcantly more
common among GIB-only participants.
Graphic training materials in conjunction with a “train-the-
trainer” video has signifcant potential for increasing Oral-SIT’s
reach by overcoming technological and literacy barriers.
Keywords
Self-implementation, Fidelity, Oral-HIV self-testing,
Tanzania
INTRODUCTION
Tanzanian youth: HIV risk and testing
Tanzanian adolescents are ranked fifth in HIV
prevalence among sub-Saharan countries [1], with
the highest prevalence observed among youth age
15–24 years [2]. This is a substantial population seg-
ment since more than half of Tanzanians, approxi-
mately 30.4 million, are under the age of 20 [3] with a
median population age of 17.4 years [4]. Low-income
Tanzanian youth have poor access to HIV-testing
and care [2, 3, 5–9]; with testing estimates ranging
widely for 15–24 year olds [1, 10]. Limited access to
HIV-testing leads to delays in receiving care and in-
creases in HIV mortality among adolescents [11, 12].
Oral HIV-testing
HIV-testing is traditionally offered in clinic settings.
Barriers to clinic-based testing include social stigma,
discrimination, and geographic distance [8, 13–15].
Oral self-implemented testing (Oral-SIT) offers a
supplemental strategy for increasing the reach of
HIV-testing services for youth. Oral-SIT allows
people to self-test under conditions of privacy that
avoid stigma and discrimination, increases repeat
and partner testing, and, with appropriate dissemin-
ation strategies, reduces transportation barriers [16,
17]. The OraQuick test by OraSure is preferred by
consumers over other self-implemented tests since
the oral swab method is less painful than finger stick
methods [17]. Prior studies assess a wide range of
Oral-SIT performance outcomes [18, 19]. Findings
show that higher levels of education and receiving
the training materials in one’s native language are as-
sociated with better performance [18, 19]. Research
in Kenya and the US illustrate that current “high lit-
eracy” variations of Oral-SIT self-training have limi-
tations [19, 20].
Self-implementation fdelity
Oral-SIT requires the person to self-implement a set
of training and testing components, and take appro-
priate follow-up actions. In this regard, Oral-SIT can
be understood within a broader implementation sci-
ence framework (i.e., a special case of program im-
plementation involving self-implementation) [18].
Self-implemented programs place a heavier burden
on the consumer because consumers must train
Overcoming cultural barriers to implementing oral HIV
self-testing with high fdelity among Tanzanian youth
Joseph A. Catania,
1
Cassidy Huun,
2
M. Margaret Dolcini,
1
Angelmary Joel Urban,
1
Nick Fleury,
1
Clinton
Ndyetabula,
3
Ryan Singh,
1
Amy W. Young,
1
Donaldson F. Conserve,
4
James Lace,
3
Joyce Samweli Msigwa
3
Correspondence to: Joseph
A Catania, Joseph.Catania@
oregonstate.edu
Cite this as: TBM 2021;11:87–95
doi: 10.1093/tbm/ibz157
© Society of Behavioral Medicine
2019. All rights reserved. For permis-
sions, please e-mail: journals.permis-
sions@oup.com.