Age and learning environment: Are children implicit
second language learners?*
KAREN LICHTMAN
Northern Illinois University, USA
(Received October – Revised July – Accepted September –
First published online February )
ABSTRACT
Children are thought to learn second languages (Ls) using primarily
implicit mechanisms, in contrast to adults, who primarily rely on
explicit language learning. This difference is usually attributed to
cognitive maturation, but adults also receive more explicit instruction
than children, which may influence their learning strategies. This
study crosses instruction condition with age, teaching forty children
aged ; to ; and forty adults an artificial mini-language under
implicit or explicit training conditions. Participants produced novel
sentences and judged sentence grammaticality equally well in either
condition, but both children and adults in the explicit training
condition developed greater awareness of the mini-language’s
structures – and greater awareness was associated with better
performance for both age groups. Results show that explicit
instruction affects children and adults in the same way, supporting the
hypothesis that age differences in implicit vs. explicit L learning are
not exclusively caused by maturation, but also influenced by
instruction.
INTRODUCTION
When it comes to long-term attainment in second language (L) learning,
children have the advantage over adults: the younger a child is when the
L acquisition process begins, the more likely that learner is to reach a
successful outcome in the new language (Krashen, Scarcella & Long,
; Singleton & Ryan, ). Second language learners who begin
exposure to the L before age seven are able to reach an ultimate
* This research was supported by National Science Foundation Linguistics program grant
BCS-. Many thanks to all of the after-school program staff, parents, and
students who helped with the study; research assistant Jeremy Schmidt; and Tania
Ionin, Silvina Montrul, Melissa Bowles, and Pam Hadley for their input. Address for
correspondence: Karen Lichtman, Department of Foreign Languages & Literatures,
Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, IL . e-mail: klichtman@niu.edu
J. Child Lang. (), –. © Cambridge University Press
doi:./S
of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305000915000598
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 54.70.40.11, on 05 Sep 2019 at 22:39:49, subject to the Cambridge Core terms