Three-Electron Two-Center Bonding in
Cycloimmonium Ylides
P. KARAFILOGLOU,
1
G. SURPATEANU
2
1
Faculty of Chemistry, Department of General and Inorganic Chemistry, POB 135, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
2
Laboratoire de Synthe `se Organique et Environnement, Universite ´ du Littoral, Co ˆte d’Opale 145, Av.
M. Schumann, 59140 Dunkerque, France
Received 15 September 2003; accepted 10 November 2003
Published online 8 March 2004 in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com).
DOI 10.1002/qua.20010
ABSTRACT: We explore the possibility that a 3-electron-2-center bonding exists in
cycloimmonium ylides. To detect this bonding in a polyatomic system, 3-electron-1-hole
density operators, characterizing a Pauling 3-electron bond, are used in the framework
of second quantization formalism. The weights of 3-electron resonance structures are
calculated and compared with the weights of 2-electron structures for the ylide bond of
pyridinium dicyanomethylide; the correlations of (12) and (1) electronic events,
involved in the 3-electron resonance structures, are also investigated. The calculations
are performed in various approximation levels, and both orthogonal and nonorthogonal
natural atomic orbitals are adopted. All calculations show that a 3-electron bond exists
between N and C atoms of ylide bond, but this bonding is not extended in C atoms of
the pyridinium group. The interactions of , electrons (at the configuration interaction
[CI] level) increase the localization of electrons, the weights of 3-electron resonance
structures, and thus the probability for 3-electron bonding. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Int J Quantum Chem 98: 456 – 464, 2004
Key words: three-electron bonds; cycloimmonium ylides; density operators; electronic
fluctuations; resonance structures; population analysis
Introduction
C
ycloimmonium ylides [1, 2], obtained from
various synthetic methods, form a well-
known class of zwitteronic compounds that display
interesting chemical behavior [3–5]. A representa-
tive compound of this class of ylides is the pyri-
dinium dicyanomethylide (PDCM), shown in Fig-
ure 1. Although this type of ylide is investigated
from various experimental and theoretical points of
view [4, 5], the possibility of 3-electron-2-center
bonding has not been explored.
Admittedly, traditional chemical formula gener-
ally plays a privileged role in all quantum chemical
interpretations and theories [6]. In this context,
Pauling’s “resonance” (or “mesomeric”) theory can
provide quite intuitive and chemically meaningful Correspondence to: P. Karafiloglou; e-mail: karafilo@chem.auth.gr
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, Vol 98, 456 – 464 (2004)
© 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.