Journal of Civil Engineering and Environmental Technology
p-ISSN: 2349-8404; e-ISSN: 2349-879X; Volume 3, Issue 6; April-June, 2016, pp. 553-557
© Krishi Sanskriti Publications
http://www.krishisanskriti.org/Publication.html
Seismic Vulnerability Assessment of an
Existing Railway Bridge
Shashikant G. Kothalkar
1
and Sachin B. Kadam
2
1
S.Y. M.Tech (Structure), Walchand college of Engineering, Sangli
2
Walchand College of Engineering, Sangli
E-mail:
1
shashi2665@gmail.com,
2
sachin.kadam@walchand sangli.ac.in
Abstract—Bridges plays a very important role in transportation
network of any country, as in India, fifty percent area of country is
susceptible to damaging earthquakes so the serviceability of bridges
is a challenging issue for transportation. Seismic assessment of
existing bridges comparative to existing buildings is less. So it is
important to evaluate the seismic risk associated with an existing
bridges and anticipate the possible damages that will occur in it
under damaging seismic events. From the seismic assessment of an
existing bridges, we will be able to take a rational decision whether
an existing bridge can be left as it is or need retrofitting for future
earthquakes.
In the present study, a two span 18.3m P.S.C. Girder Bridge existed
at chainage 74110m in railway route from Amravati–Narkhed
(Amravati, Maharashtra, India) across Sukhi river is taken as a case
study. Non-linear pushover analysis method can be used to evaluate
the structural behaviour of bridges in the inelastic range and to get
the failure pattern in different components of bridges when subjected
to damaging seismic events. But in pushover analysis, only
fundamental mode is considered as dominant. So this limitation of the
pushover analysis method increases our attention towards seismic
vulnerability assessment and development of fragility curves. So
fragility curves are also developed for four different damage states
ranging from slight damage to complete damage along with pushover
analysis for the case study.
Keywords: Prestressed Bridge, Seismic Vulnerability, Fragility
curves, Nonlinear Static (Pushover) Analysis, SAP 2000
1. INTRODUCTION
Indian Railways have many bridges and most of them are not
designed according to modern seismic design codes. And also
older structures show insufficient capacity like low
deformation capacity. So it is requisite to do seismic
assessment of an existing bridges.
In the linear method of analysis, bridge action is within elastic
range and results of the method like force and displacement
are quite high. So it will make uneconomical bridge design.
That’s why nowadays non-linear analysis like pushover
analysis method can be used to know the non-linear behavior
of the structure as well as to draw the failure pattern for
different components of the bridges. So the first step of the
project work is to carry out pushover analysis for the case
study. But the main assumption of pushover analysis method
is the response of the structure is mainly controlled by its
fundamental mode. This force us to give attention on seismic
vulnerability assessment and development of fragility curves.
Modal analysis of a 3D bridge model reveals that it has many
closely-spaced modes. Participating mass ratio for the higher
modes is very high. Therefore, pushover analysis with single
load pattern may not yield correct results for a bridge model.
Fragility curves of bridges can be developed empirically as
well as analytically. Empirical fragility curves are usually
developed based on the damage reports from past earthquakes.
Since earthquake damage data are very scarce in developing
countries like India, analytical development of fragility is the
only feasible approach of development of fragility curve.
Analytical fragility curves are developed from seismic
response analysis of bridges, and regression analysis of
simulated response data to establish the probabilistic
characteristics of structural demand as a function a ground
motion parameter.
2. SCOPE AND OBJECTIVES:
In this paper, an attempt is made to study and compare the
effects of earthquake on an existing railway bridge using
SAP2000 and to check its vulnerability. By using
methodology of Hazard–US (HAZUS) (MH-MR1, 2003)
variability in demand and capacity will be estimated and to
obtain the fragility curves for the existing railway bridge by
analytical approach.
3. NONLINEAR STATIC (PUSHOVER) ANALYSIS:
Pushover analysis is a simplified, static, nonlinear analysis
under a predefined pattern of permanent vertical loads and
gradually increasing lateral loads. Typically, the first pushover
load case is used to apply gravity load and then subsequent
lateral pushover load cases are specified to start from the final
conditions of the gravity pushover. Typically, a gravity load