GÁBOR KOVÁCS
CAN POWER BE HUMANIZED?
The Notions of Elite and Legitimation in István Bibó’s Political
Philosophy
1
ABSTRACT. Istvan Bibó was the clandestine politological authority during the
late Kadar period, and was rediscovered after the fall of communism. The essay
examines and reconstructs the notions of elite and legitimation in Bibó’s political
philosophy. As a young thinker he confronted the value crisis between the two
world wars. He was influenced by Oswald Spengler’s and Ortega y Gasset’s
theories of elites. The essay analyses the similarities and differences in their
views. In Bibó’s conceptual world, the theory of elites is connected with the issue
of legitimation, because in his opinion the crisis of elites always results in a crisis
of legitimation. Bibó’s analysis of elites, their social responsibilities as well as the
types of legitimization are highly instructive for us since they help us rethink our
conceptions of the social roles of elites and political legitimation under conditions
of globalisation.
KEY WORDS: Istvan Bibó, value crisis, elites, sense of social responsibilities,
types of legitimation, humanization of power
István Bibó (1911–1979) was one of Central Europe’s most
profound thinkers in recent history. It is not an easy task to define
his field of interest. Was he a historian or a legal scientist, a polit-
ical thinker, maybe a politician? He was all and none. In his early
works, he was interested mostly in legal sciences. Between 1935
and 1944, he wrote a series of essays concerned with jurispru-
dence. They predicted the direction in which he was to turn after
the Second World War. In 1935 he published an essay entitled Coer-
cion, Law and Liberty [Kényszer, jog, szabadság].
2
In this work,
the young legal scientist investigated the relation between the three
factors listed in the title. In his interpretation, coercion and liberty do
not exclude one another. Moreover, they exist in a complementary
relationship: coercion cannot eliminate or destroy liberty because
someone under very strict pressure or coerced to do something is not
deprived totally of a modicum of liberty. However, liberty is an inner
Studies in East European Thought 51: 307–327, 1999.
© 1999 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.