2010 APDS SPRING MEETING
A Primer on How to Select Osteopathic
Applicants to an Allopathic General Surgery
Residency
Paul J. Schenarts, MD,* Paula M. Termuhlen, MD,
†
Jason Pasley, DO,
†
Joel S. Rose, MD, and
Mark L. Friedell, MD
‡
*Department of Surgery, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina, and
†
Department of Surgery,
Wright State University, Dayton, Ohio, and the
‡
Orlando Regional Medical Center, Orlando, Florida
KEY WORDS: surgical education, osteopathic training, resi-
dent selection
COMPETENCY: Systems Based Practice, Interpersonal and
Communication Skills, Professionalism
INTRODUCTION
As part of Education Week 2009 in Salt Lake City, Utah, the
Association of Program Directors in Surgery hosted a panel
discussion addressing the integration of osteopathic graduates
into allopathic general surgery residency training programs.
This article summarizes this panel discussion and the questions
asked by members of the audience.
With an increasing number of osteopathic medical school
graduates, applications to allopathic general surgery residency
training programs have been on the rise. Additionally, military
scholarships are offered to students at both osteopathic and
allopathic schools, increasing the percentage of osteopathic
graduates seeking general surgery training in allopathic pro-
grams with a military affiliation.
The purpose of this work is to provide program directors and
faculty members involved with resident selection a primer of
information about the expanding role osteopathic physicians,
answer potential biases and frequently asked questions about
osteopathic applicants and provide practical information on
matching osteopathic residents into an allopathic general sur-
gery residency program.
The Expected Rise of Osteopathic Applicants
There has been a dramatic increase of osteopathic graduates apply-
ing for allopathic general surgical training. The development of
multiple new colleges of osteopathic medicine and expansion of
already existing schools is expected to generate 5227 first-year stu-
dents by 2012, which represents an increase of 1380 students
(36%) since 2006. By 2016, the number of osteopathic graduates
is expected to increase by an additional 62% over current numbers,
whereas allopathic medical school growth is projected to increase
by only 21%.
1,2
By 2019, it is predicted that 25% of all United
States medical school graduates produced annually will be doctors
of osteopathic medicine (DOs).
1
The residency training of this
increased number of osteopathic graduates cannot be accommo-
dated within the American Osteopathic Association postdoctoral
training programs and a significant number will enter the allo-
pathic system. Between 1985 and 2006 the number of osteopathic
physicians (DOs) training in Accreditation Council for Graduate
Medical Education (ACGME) postdoctoral training has increased
419%.
1
Currently, only 40% of osteopathic graduates enter osteo-
pathic training programs, whereas 60% enter an ACGME training
program.
3
Traditionally, osteopathic medical school graduates have en-
tered primary care specialties or rural practice. Between 1994
and 1996, DOs accounted for only 1.2% of graduates entering
general surgery residencies.
4
However, the number of osteo-
pathic graduates entering surgical residencies is increasing
steadily. In a survey of 1882 osteopathic graduates in 2004, the
number entering surgical residencies had increased to 9%.
5
However, this increase in DOs entering surgical residency may
be misleading, as a large number of these may be nondesignated
preliminary internships, and the number actually completing
the general surgery training is likely far less.
Given this increase in the number of osteopathic graduates and
likely increase in those applying to ACGME surgical residencies,
general surgery program directors will need a greater understand-
ing of how to select DOs for their training programs.
Brief History of Osteopathic Medicine
Dr. Andrew Taylor Still, a Missouri practitioner and Civil War
surgeon, established osteopathic medicine as an offshoot of
Correspondence: Inquiries to Paul J. Schenarts, MD, Department of Surgery, Brody
School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC 27858; fax: (252)
847-8208; e-mail: schenartsp@ecu.edu
Presented at the 2009 meeting of the Association of Program Directors in Surgery held
in Salt Lake, City, Utah.
Journal of Surgical Education
•
© 2011 Association of Program Directors in Surgery 1931-7204/$30.00
Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.jsurg.2011.01.001
239