Education 2014, 4(2): 35-40
DOI: 10.5923/j.edu.20140402.04
Validating the Effects of Inclusive Childcare with the
Interaction Rating Scale
Anme T.
1,*
, Tanaka E.
1
, Sugisawa Y.
2
, Matsumoto M.
3
, Watanabe T.
4
,
Tomisaki E.
5
, Tokutake K.
1
, Miyazaki K.
6
, Edamoto S.
6
1
Faculty of Medicine, University of Tsukuba, Ibaragi, Japan
2
UsyukuCity, Ibaragi, Japan
3
Futaba Nursery, Tokyo, Japan
4
Faculty of Nursing, Ashikaga University, Tochigi, Japan
5
Sofia University, Tokyo, Japan
6
Rokokan, Osaka, Japan
Abstract This study aimed to validate the effects of inclusion in center-based childcare, focusing on the inclusion of
children with disabilities. One hundred thirty-eight 3 to 12-year-olds participated in this study. Participants were required to
complete a 5-minute interaction session and were evaluated using the Interaction Rating Scale between Children (IRSC) as
an evidence-based practical index of social skills. Significantly higher IRSC self-control scores were observed in
interactions between typically developing children and children with disabilities than in normal children pairs. Additionally,
behaviors reflecting the IRSC items, “explains his/her opinion logically” and “explains his/her opinion based on the level of
competence/ability of the partner” were more frequently observed in interactions involving peers with disabilities than in
those involving only typically developing peers. These results suggest that inclusive childcare may be effective in
enhancing child social competence, especially self-control and flexibility/adaptability, depending on interaction partners’
needs for care.
Keywords Inclusion, Interaction, Peer, Evaluation, Scale
1. Introduction
In early childhood education and care, “inclusive
childcare” describes the practice of including children with
disabilities in a childcare setting with typically developing
children of similar ages, with specialized instruction and
support when needed. Children with special needs and
typically developing children can both benefit from sharing
learning environments and enjoy the rich experiences and
relationships that inclusive childcare centers offer growing
hearts and minds.
Many studies all over the world have demonstrated that
inclusion, done well, can be a very positive experience for
both young children with special needs and their typically
developing peers [1-3]. For example, children with special
needs can learn and acquire valuable opportunities to
practice various social skills in real-world situations by
observing and interacting with other children of similar ages.
Meanwhile, typically developing children can benefit
immensely from interacting with a child with special needs
* Corresponding author:
anmet@md.tsukuba.ac.jp (Anme T.)
Published online at http://journal.sapub.org/edu
Copyright © 2014 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved
in their childcare program, as such interaction can help
typically developing children develop an increased
appreciation and acceptance of individual differences, as
well as greater empathy for others.
Studies have shown that children who continually
interact with children with disabilities developed attitudes
of acceptance and understanding not usually present in
children who have not had such exposure [4-6]. Enhancing
children’s social competence while they are young is both a
tremendous responsibility and a privilege with potentially
long-lasting effects. In fact, peer interactions provide
opportunities for children to learn social skills from each
other and understand rules for appropriate behaviors in
different settings. Moreover, social relationships established
through interactions are a major source of security and
belonging [7].
Social competence is defined as the ability to understand
others in the context of social interactions and engage in
smooth communication with them. Thus, social competence
must be evaluated according to the interactions an
individual has with his/her social environment [8]. To
enable practically effective, context-based evaluations of
social competence throughout the lifespan, the Interaction
Rating Scale between Children (IRSC) and Interaction
Rating Scale Advanced (IRSA) were developed, with which