A Scalable and Secure Position-Based Routing
Protocol for MANETs
Liana Khamis Qabajeh, Miss Laiha Mat Kiah
Faculty of Computer Science and IT
University of Malaya
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Mohammad Moustafa Qabajeh
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering
IIUM
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Abstract—Mobile Ad-Hoc Networks (MANETs) are becoming
increasingly applicable in different fields. Securing MANETs
routing protocols is considered as one of the most difficult
areas to deal with as opponents can add themselves to a
MANET using the existing common routing protocols. This
paper proposes a new routing protocol; ARANz, which is an
extension of the original Authenticated Routing for Ad-Hoc
Networks (ARAN). Apart from the authentication methods
adopted from ARAN, ARANz aims to increase security,
achieve robustness and solve the single point of attack and
failure problems by introducing multiple local certificate
authority servers. Via dealing with the network as zones and
using restricted directional flooding, our new model exhibits
better scalability and performance. Through simulation we
evaluated ARANz and compared it with the original ARAN.
Simulation results show that ARANz is able to effectively and
efficiently discover secure routes within relatively large
networks with large number of mobile nodes.
Keywords-Secure; Scalable; Position-Based; Routing; Ad-
Hoc Network; MANETs
I. INTRODUCTION
Mobile Ad-Hoc Network (MANET) is a self-
configuring network of mobile devices connected by
wireless links. A key component of Ad-Hoc networks is an
efficient routing protocol since all devices in the network act
as routers. Another important issue is securing the routing
protocol specially that the concept and structure of Ad-Hoc
networks make them prone to be easily attacked.
Many secure routing protocols have been developed for
Ad-Hoc networks such as the Authenticated Routing for Ad-
Hoc Networks (ARAN) [1]. ARAN provides authenticated
route discovery, setup and maintenance. Main objective of
ARAN is to protect against attacks from malicious nodes in a
managed-open environment where a small amount of prior
security coordination is expected. Before entering the Ad-
Hoc network each node requests a certificate from a trusted
certificate authority. Every node that forwards a request or a
reply must sign it so that the successor node can check the
validity of the previous one. We observed that although
ARAN is robust against a large number of attacks, it bases
on a centralized trust hence suffers from the single point of
failure and attack problems as well as a scalability problem
since route request packets are flooded to the entire network.
Recently, position-based routing protocols exhibit high
scalability, performance and robustness against frequent
topological changes. Position-based routing protocols use the
geographical position of nodes to make routing decisions.
Hence, the source node is supposed to obtain its own
geographical position as well as the destination’s position.
Usually, this information is obtained via Global Positioning
System (GPS) and location services. Position-based routing
protocols are categorized into three main groups:
restricted directional flooding, greedy forwarding and
hierarchical routing protocols. We note that restricted
directional flooding has better performance than topology-
based and other position-based routing protocols. Moreover,
limited work has been done to secure position-based routing.
Consequently, it is an important issue to find a scalable
and secure position-based routing protocol for Ad-Hoc
networks. A new model of hierarchal and distributed routing
protocol, ARANz has been proposed in this work. Through
simulation we evaluated ARANz and compared it with the
original ARAN. Preliminary results show that ARANz is
able to discover secure routes efficiently within relatively
large networks having large number of nodes.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II
presents the newly proposed protocol. Section III contains
simulated comparison between ARAN and ARANz
protocols. We analyze and discuss our findings in Section
IV. Section V presents our conclusions and future directions.
II. PROPOSED PROTOCOL
In this section a new routing scheme is proposed. The
proposed protocol is named ARANz since it adopts the
authentication steps used with the ARAN protocol and deals
with the network as zones. ARANz uses cryptographic
certificates to prevent most of the attacks against Ad-Hoc
routing protocols and detect erratic behavior. ARANz
introduces a hierarchal distributed routing algorithm, which
aims to improve performance of the routing protocol and
distribute load by dividing the area into zones. It aims to
achieve robustness, solve the single point of failure problem
and avoid the single point of attack problem by distributing
trust among multiple Local Certificate Authority (LCA)
servers. Each zone has multiple LCAs that collaborate
together to issue certificates for nodes inside that zone.
ARANz tries to exhibit better scalability, performance
and robustness against frequent topological changes by using
restricted directional flooding. Whenever a node needs to
communicate with another one the former will get the latter’s
position through the LCAs of its zone, then the route request
Annual International Conference on Network Technologies & Communications (NTC 2010)
Copyright © GSTF 2010
ISBN: 978-981-08-7656-2
doi:10.5176/978-981-08-7656-2 NTC2010-9
N-7