Observation of a Rare Earth Ion−Extractant Complex Arrested at the
Oil−Water Interface During Solvent Extraction
Wei Bu,*
,†
Hao Yu,
†
Guangming Luo,
‡,⊥
Mrinal K. Bera,
†
Binyang Hou,
†
Adam W. Schuman,
†
Binhua Lin,
∥
Mati Meron,
∥
Ivan Kuzmenko,
§
Mark R. Antonio,
‡
L. Soderholm,*
,‡
and Mark L. Schlossman*
,†
†
Department of Physics, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60607, United States
‡
Chemical Sciences and Engineering Division, and
§
XSD, Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, Illinois
60439, United States
∥
Center for Advanced Radiation Sources, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60637, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Selective extraction of metal ions from a complex aqueous mixture into an organic
phase is used to separate toxic or radioactive metals from polluted environments and nuclear waste,
as well as to produce industrially relevant metals, such as rare earth ions. Selectivity arises from the
choice of an extractant amphiphile, dissolved in the organic phase, which interacts preferentially
with the target metal ion. The extractant-mediated process of ion transport from an aqueous to an
organic phase takes place at the aqueous−organic interface; nevertheless, little is known about the
molecular mechanism of this process despite its importance. Although state-of-the-art X-ray
scattering is uniquely capable of probing molecular ordering at a liquid−liquid interface with
subnanometer spatial resolution, utilizing this capability to investigate interfacial dynamical
processes of short temporal duration remains a challenge. We show that a temperature-driven
adsorption transition can be used to turn the extraction on and off by controlling adsorption and
desorption of extractants at the oil−water interface. Lowering the temperature through this
transition immobilizes a supramolecular ion−extractant complex at the interface during the
extraction of rare earth erbium ions. Under the conditions of these experiments, the ion−extractant
complexes condense into a two-dimensional inverted bilayer, which is characterized on the molecular scale with synchrotron X-
ray reflectivity and fluorescence measurements. Raising the temperature above the transition leads to Er ion extraction as a result
of desorption of ion−extractant complexes from the interface into the bulk organic phase. XAFS measurements of the ion−
extractant complexes in the bulk organic phase demonstrate that they are similar to the interfacial complexes.
1. INTRODUCTION
The transport of ions across liquid−liquid interfaces underlies a
wide variety of biological, environmental, and industrial
processes.
1−3
Although there have been studies focused on
various aspects of metal−ion phase transfer, a paucity of
relevant data has prohibited the development of a molecular-
level understanding of events occurring at the interface. Recent
advances in X-ray interface-sensitive techniques
4
now extend
the capability to probe molecular-level speciation and
organization to liquid−liquid interfaces. Herein, we apply
these techniques to probe molecular-level organization at an
aqueous−organic solution interface with specific relevance to
solvent extraction.
Solvent extraction, an important industrial process for
separating, isolating, and thus purifying metal ions, involves
the transfer of a targeted species between two immiscible
solution phases.
5−8
The process involves contact of an aqueous
phase containing a mixture of ionic species with an organic
phase to which the targeted metal species is to be selectively
transferred by complexation with an amphiphilic extractant
molecule, which serves to solubilize the metal cation in the
nonpolar phase. Until recently, the major energetic driver for
this process has been thought to center on small differences in
molecular energetics favoring the molecular metal−extractant
complex.
9
New evidence is changing this perspective,
suggesting instead that efficient metal extraction processes
may involve the formation of extractant-based clusters in the
organic phase.
10,11
Described in terms of reverse micelles, these
clusters are comprised of extractants that self-organize. Critical
to, but missing from this model, is knowledge of how the
micelles are formed and how the targeted ions become
enclosed in these supramolecular structures. Our X-ray studies
provide the basis for a molecular-level understanding of
interactions and organization at the liquid−liquid interface
through evidence of an interfacial route to such supramolecular
structures. Although this work focuses on a system of relevance
to solvent extraction, the results provide new insight into
molecular-level processes at liquid−liquid interfaces.
Received: June 6, 2014
Revised: August 18, 2014
Published: August 19, 2014
Article
pubs.acs.org/JPCB
© 2014 American Chemical Society 10662 dx.doi.org/10.1021/jp505661e | J. Phys. Chem. B 2014, 118, 10662−10674