RADHIK VIRURU and GAILE S. CANNELLA
Department of Educational Curriculum and Instruction, College of Education, Texas A&M Universit, College Station, TX 77843-4232
A Indian Voice in the Education
of Young Children
Currently the field of early childhood education
places great emphasis on particular environmental
conditions that are consistent with constructions of
child development (Polakow, 1992; Bredekemp,
1987). However, child study conducted within an an
thropological famework supports the notion that
children not only survive but thrive in a variety of dif
frent environments. This perspective gives frther
credence to the idea that human learning is a cultur
ally constructed process that is mu ltidirectiona l and
multidimensional. To apply any "universal " princi
ples of development and learning t o diverse cultural
contexts is to disempower the children in those con
texts (News and Mallory, 1994). Das (1995) makes
the point that it is necessary fr people who really
wish to represent diverse voices fith flly to create
their own spaces within broad genres of research.
Giving voice to groups that have traditionally been si
lenced requires that their constructions of li f and
education be examined in a variety of di ferent set
tings and within a variety
.
of communities that have
experienced difering survival histories. The purpose
of this naturalistic study was therefre to provide an
ethnographic description of a cultural setting in which
young children are educated in India, to hear the
voices of particular people in a particular context.
Ogbu ( 1 98 1 ) introduced the notion that constructions
of educational practice emerge fom the needs of a par
ticular cultural group surviving and thriving in a particu
lar situation. The children are then educated according
to the needs of the community. What we hope to show
in this paper is that the young children in an Indian pre
school are fnctioning in an environment that is con
structed out of the needs and values of their community.
As a country, India is so large (with a population
close to 900 million) and so culturally diverse (with
f feen official languages and thousands of dialects)
that education is by necessity diverse in nature. Most
lower- and upper-middle class children, however, are
introduced to reading and writing at an early age
(generally starting at age three). There is widespread
concern among educators, possibly reflecting chi ld
development perspectives that dominate the field of
early childhood education, that this may be putting
too much pressure on children too early (Kumar,
1993). However, the curriculum continues to consist
mostly of formal instructi on in reading, writing, arith
metic, and direct instruction (Kaul, 1992).
Historical and Cultural Contex
Formal preschool education did not exist in India
until the turn of the century when it was introduced
by Wester missionaries. It was during the 1930s that
Maria Montessori visited India several times which
led to the setting up of Montessori training institutes
in the south and west of India (Muralidharan, 1991 ).
Since India gained independence in 194 7, education
in the early years has received even more attention.
The government of India currently runs a program
known as the Integrated Child Development Services
(ICDS) which serves approximately 5 million chil
dren, ofering health, nutrition, and education to chil
dren under the age of six and their mothers.
Oral Traditions
In the Vedic period (5000 B.C . to 2000 B.C.), chil
dren were placed under the care and direction of the
308 Interational Joural of Educational Reform, Volume 6, No. 3 I July1997
1 056-7879/97/03 0308-08 $10.00/0
© 1 997 Technomic Publishing Co., Inc.